What are the Benedictine Substitute? (Vieux carre, Drambuie)

“Is there a substitute for benedictine”- The most commonly asked question comes from every food lover.

You’ll know when you taste this drink’s exquisite flavor, but if you’re curious and want to learn more about its alternatives, don’t worry. Here it is from Drambuie to Amaretto; all are included.

What is Benedictine Solution? What are the ingredients of Bénédictine?

Benedictine is honey-based alcohol, common in cooking, and made from reputedly flavored with twenty-seven flowers, berries, herbs, roots, and spices.

What is the flavor of benedictine?

Some people say that the flavor of benedictine is fruity, while others say that it is vanilla- or almond-flavored. 

However, most people clearly agree that the flavor is quite sweet.

What can you use instead of Bénédictine?- 10 Best Alternatives for Benedictine Substitute

10. AMARETTO- Almond Flavor Benedictine Alternative 

Amaretto is a sweet, almond-flavored liqueur that is often enjoyed on its own or in mixed drinks. It can also be substituted for Benedictine in recipes.

Amaretto is a sweet, almond-flavoured liqueur that is often enjoyed on its own or in mixed drinks. It can also be substituted for Benedictine in recipes.

Amaretto should be stored in a cool, dry place for up to one year.

Some popular cocktails that include Amaretto are the Amaretto sour, the cherry cola cocktail, and the peach cobbler. 

Amaretto is often used to make frosting for cakes or cookies because it adds sweetness without extra fat or sugar. There are many different flavors of Amaretto, including chocolate, apricot, and nectarine.

9. GLAYVA- For A Perfect Grilling Replacement for Benedictine

Glayva is a Scottish liqueur made with honey, whisky, and herbs. It has a sweet, herbal taste that makes it a great addition to cocktails or recipes. 

best benedictine substitute in grilling is glayva.

Glayva can be used as a replacement for Benedictine in most recipes. 

If you’re using Glayva in place of Benedictine, the proportions remain basically the same. 

The one difference is that you may need to add a bit more sugar when using Glayva since it’s sweeter than most brands of Benedictine.

Glayva can be stored at room temperature or in the fridge. It will keep for up to 2 years when stored properly.

So, if you’re looking for a delicious and unique liqueur to add to your cocktails or recipes, try Glayva! It’s a Scottish staple that is sure to impress your guests.

8. GRAND MARINER for Your Next Roasting instead of Benedictine 

Grand Marnier is a French orange-flavored liqueur created in 1892 by Louis-Alexandre Marnier Lapostolle. It is made from cognac and triple sec with the addition of natural orange flavor.

try grand mariner for your next roasting instead of benedictine

Grand Marnier is used in mixed drinks, such as the Grand Margarita and the Grand Marnier Centenaire (100 years), and in many dessert sauces and pastries.

Conversion: 1/4 oz. Grand Marnier + 3/4 oz Triple Sec + 3 oz. Tequila + 1 splash Sour Mix = Margarita

Storing: Unopened bottles of orange liqueur can be stored in a cool, dry place for up to 3 years. Once opened, the liqueur should be stored in the refrigerator and last for about 6 months.

Grand Marnier can also be used to replace Benedictine in many recipes. For example, the sauce for Crepes Suzette calls for 1/4 cup Grand Marnier to replace the 1/4 cup Benedictine. 

This substitution works out just fine since it already has the same amount of alcohol as Benedictine.

Serve chilled on the rocks or neat, over ice. It can also be used in mixed drinks, dessert sauces, and pastries.

7. BRANDY- Another Benedict Substitute Suitable for Cooking

Brandy is a distilled wine-based liquor. It is usually bottled in a cask and aged for a minimum of two years, although some types of brandy are aged for much longer. 

brandy is a popular substitute suitable for cooking

Brandy has a smooth, mellow flavor that can be enjoyed on its own or used in mixed drinks.

When substituting brandy for Benedictine in cocktails, it is important to remember that brandy is a much stronger liquor than Benedictine. 

Use one part brandy to two or three parts of other liquors or mixers.

Brandy should be stored in a cool, dark place where it will stay fresh for up to five years. It can also be frozen for a period of up to six months.

In addition to its use in cocktails, brandy can also be used in cooking. It is a popular ingredient in dishes like mulled wine and apple cider. Brandy can also make a simple syrup that can be added to cocktails or used as a flavoring agent in other dishes.

6. CAMPARI- A Good Replacement for Benedictine in diverse recipes

Campari is a unique and delicious Italian liqueur flavored with herbs, fruits, and seeds that can be enjoyed on its own or in cocktails.

It has a bitter flavor that derives from the infusion of more than ninety different plants that are collected all over Italy. 

campari is a popular cooking ingredient, you can use it in place of benedictine.

Campari has a unique, intense flavor that can be difficult to describe. It’s simultaneously sweet and bitter, with fruity undertones. 

It’s been compared to a cross between soda and red wine by some people. It can be enjoyed on its own as an aperitif or used in cocktails.

Campari is often substituted for Benedictine in recipes and added to food items like ice cream or pizza. It can make cocktails such as the Negroni and the Americano. 

Campari should be kept in a cold, dark location. If correctly maintained, it can last up to 2 years. Campari can be frozen as well.

Campari has a variety of other uses. Like in soapmaking and sprayed on plants to repel insects. In Italy, Campari is sometimes used as a household cleaner.

5. ITALICUS – Perfect Alternate to Benedictine Cocktail

Italicus is nothing but gorgeous pale gold color glimmering over the precious liquid which it contains. 

Its aroma, full of power but also incredibly subtle at once – it smells awesome! Italicus is an aromatic liqueur made of 8 different herbs and spices, flowers honey, and a touch of wine.

italicus is a perfect alternative to a benedictine cocktail

Italicus is very versatile and can be used as a digestive after dinner or before a meal – it helps enhance the flavors of your food. 

You can also use Italicus for decoration, simply pour a few drops over your desserts! Or how about adding some flavor to cocktails? Just replace Bénédictine with Italicus in your recipes.

When it comes to storage, Italicus can be kept for up to 3 years if you keep it in the dark place at a temperature of 16-18 degrees Celsius.

Expect these, Italicus is used for other things such as grilling. For example, you can add Italicus to chicken or fish while on the grill to give it a unique flavor. 

This is a terrific way to change up your regular grilling recipes. 

You can add Italicus to a delicious salad dressing. It’s vital not to use too much because a little goes a long way. Just mix it with some lemon juice, oil and salt, and pepper, then drizzle the dressing over your favorite greens.

So what are you waiting for? Get creative in the kitchen and add some Italicus to your dishes! You won’t be disappointed.

4. A Very Similar to Benedictine- ITALIAN AMARO 

Italian Amaro is a sweet, bitter type of liqueur with an herbal taste. It is made from various herbs and can be used as a substitute for Benedictine in recipes. 

Italian Amaro can also be stored for long periods and has other uses in cooking and grilling.

Italian Amaro is a sweet, bitter type of liqueur with an herbal taste. It is made from various herbs and can be used as a substitute for Benedictine in recipes. 
Italian Amaro

You can serve after dinner in the same manner as port or sherry. However, it can also enhance sauces and marinades for cooking fish and roasts such as lamb or pork belly (intensely flavored cuts) and vegetables like potatoes, beets, and carrots.

Italian Amaro also makes a delicious addition to cocktails, such as the Negroni or Americano. It can also be used in place of Benedictine in recipes that call for that liqueur.

Italian Amaro can be stored at room temperature for long periods. However, if stored in a cool, dark place, it can last even longer.

3. Use SAKE instead of Benedictine in Cooking

Sake, also known as Nihonshu, is a rice-based special drink made from the fermentation of polished rice and native to Japanese cuisine. 

It has an alcoholic content (14%-16%) and can be served either hot or cold, depending on how warm or chilled. 

The taste of brewed Sake varies according to ingredients used in brewing processes. Still, most people say it has a slightly sweet and fruity flavor with a refreshing finish.

When used in cooking, Sake can add flavor and depth to dishes and make them moister. Additionally, Sake can also be used as a marinade for meat or seafood before grilling or a dipping sauce.

To avoid spoilage, the bottle should not be stored for too long once it has been opened. If you’re short on time and don’t want to make a trip to the store, Sake can also be substituted for Benedictine in many cocktails or recipes.

Sake is one of the most versatile alcoholic beverages and can be enjoyed by people of all ages. 

There’s always something new to learn about Sake, whether you’re a novice or an expert. So grab a bottle (or two) and get started on your own Sake journey!

Read More- Non alcoholic Mirin Alternatives for Cooking

2. CHARTREUSE- A Typical Substitute for Benedictine in making Dessert

Chartreuse is a French liqueur named after the Chartreuse Mountains. It’s a secret blend of 130 plants and flowers. 

The color of Chartreuse can vary from yellow to green, depending on how it was made. In some cases, there’s even red or brown Chartreuse.

CHARTREUSE A Typical Substitute for Benedictine in making Dessert

The taste of Chartreuse is unique. There’s no other liqueur-like it. It’s sweet, herbal, and a little spicy. Some people say it tastes like licorice or anise. Others say it has a citrusy flavor.

You can use Chartreuse in place of Benedictine in most recipes. 

Just keep in mind that Chartreuse is much sweeter than Benedictine, so adjust the sweetness level accordingly.

Chartreuse can be stored for up to 10 years if you keep it in a cool, dark place. It’s also great for cooking and grilling. Use it in marinades, sauces, or salad dressings. It’s a terrific method to give your cuisine a distinct flavor.

Chartreuse is also great in many other dishes, such as rice and pasta dishes. It is a very versatile liqueur that can be used in many different ways. 

1. DRAMBUIE – A Great Replacement for Benedictine for cooking

Drambuie is a Scottish whiskey liqueur made with honey, herbs, and spices. It has a sweet, fruity flavor that is similar to Benedictine.

It can be used in place of Benedictine in recipes, or it can be enjoyed on its own as a drink. Drambuie can be stored for up to 2 years.

Drambuie can be enjoyed on its own as a drink, or it can be used in mixed drinks because it adds sweetness and flavor. It can also be enjoyed after dinner with coffee.

It pairs well with strong cheeses like Stilton, Cheddar, Gouda, and Romano. It works well both hot and cold drinks; warm milk or tea or iced coffee.

drambuie is a great replacement for benedictine for cooking

Drambuie can also be used in cooking and grilling. For example, it can be used in place of honey in a barbecue sauce or as a glaze for ham. It can also use flavor dishes such as ice cream or sorbet.

Some people use Drambuie as a cure for a hangover. It is said to help settle the stomach and restore balance.

Drambuie has a sweet, fruity flavor that is similar to Benedictine. It can be used in place of Benedictine in recipes, or it can be enjoyed on its own as a drink.

Drambuie can be stored for up to 2 years.

Substitute for benedictine in Vieux carre

The Vieux Carre is a cocktail that I have always loved but never got around to making – mainly because of the benedictine. 

The recipe calls for 1/2 ounce, which sounds like a lot. However, it’s just 1 tablespoon of Plymouth gin infused with 2 1/4 teaspoons crushed green and black peppercorns, 2 teaspoons allspice, 1 teaspoon cinnamon, then topped off with 1 tablespoon benedictine. 

This would be great to make when in need of something quick and equally impressive – just don’t tell the guests it’s an easy substitute!

I hope you enjoy this appetizing take on the Vieux Carre recipe! It’s perfect for those cold winter days when you need a drink that will warm you up from the inside out. Cheers!

What do you use Benedictine for?

Benedictine is a liqueur that is made from herbs and spices. It is often used as a digestive aid, and it can also be used in cocktails.

To be honest, I use Benedictine for anything that I want to taste sweet. 

We even have a dish in Japan called “Oyakodon,” chicken and egg on rice with some mushrooms and other ingredients. 

But instead of using sugar, we add Benedictine liqueur to make it sweeter. In France, people love to put Benedictine in coffee.

How do you store Benedictine?

It is best stored in the bottle in which it was bought. Benedictine bottles are often made of clear glass to keep sunlight off the drink. 

The high sugar content means that, if exposed to light, benedictine will eventually ferment and spoil its flavor. 

A wine-making friend of mine also advised me never to store this liqueur in the fridge, no matter how tempted I might be to do so. The cold will dull its flavors.

So where should you store your benedictine then? Somewhere dark and cool is ideal. A cupboard or pantry is perfect. If you don’t have either of those, try a spot near the window but not in any direct sunlight.

Benedictine vs Chartreuse – What’s the difference?

The main difference between Benedictine and Chartreuse is that Benedictine is a sweet liqueur, while Chartreuse is a dry liqueur. 

Both are made from herbs and spices, but the proportions and ingredients vary.

Benedictine was originally created in the 16th century by a French monk named Dom Bernardo Vincelli. He had learned herbal medicine in France. 

Chartreuse was created in 1737 by French monks from the Carthusian order. 

They were looking for a tonic to help them stay healthy and prolong their lives. The recipe is a secret, but it is thought to include more than 130 herbs and spices. 

The Carthusian monks opened a distillery in the town of Voiron to produce Chartreuse.

Benedictine is 43% alcohol by volume, while Chartreuse is 80% alcohol by volume. This means that Benedictine is diluted with water before bottled, while Chartreuse is not.

Both Benedictine and Chartreuse are considered “digestifs,” meaning they are drunk after a meal to help with digestion.

Benedictine is available in green and yellow varieties. The green variety is sweeter and suitable for drinking undiluted, while the yellow variety can be diluted with water or used in cooking. 

Chartreuse comes in two varieties: Green and Yellow. Green Chartreuse has a sweeter taste than the yellow variety.

As nouns, the difference between benedictine and chartreuse is that benedictine is a liqueur flavored with spices, sugar, caramel, plants, etc. 

While chartreuse is a color of medium yellow-green named after the liquor made by monks in the French town of Chartres.

So what’s the difference between Benedictine and Chartreuse? 

The main difference is that Benedictine is a yellowish-brown herbal liqueur. At the same time, Chartreuse is a French liqueur made by Carthusian monks. 

Another difference would be that Benedictine is simply a brand name of alcohol, specifically a herbal liqueur. In contrast, Chartreuse has always been sold under the same name.

Read More- Ume Plum Vinegar Substitute

What do I substitute for benedictine?

  • · Drambuie
  • · Campari
  • · Grand Mariner
  • · Amaretto
  • · Sake
  • · Glayva

FAQs Related To Benedictine & its Alternative

Q1. Is Cointreau similar to Bénédictine?

This is one of the most often asked questions I’ve gotten since starting this website.

Now, these are two very different liqueurs with different strengths and volumes. Still, perhaps there are similarities in their taste profiles or flavor histories that make them appear to be close relatives. 

Let’s take a look at the facts…


Cointreau is an orange-flavored liqueur made by combining bitter and sweet oranges known as Seville oranges. 

The base spirit used in Cointreau is a neutral white grape spirit, with only sugar added before bottling. 

Once bottled, more sugar syrup or some other sweetener can be added to taste if desired.


Bénédictine is a complex herbal liqueur based on a recipe that was supposedly given to the monks of the Benedictine order in the 16th century by an angel. 

It contains 27 herbs and spices and a blend of sweet and dry wines. 

The base spirit used is brandy, then distilled again with the herbs and spices. It is bottled at 27% ABV.

Q2. Is Bénédictine a cognac?

The name Bénédictine is known as a mix of herbs and spices, probably most well-known as an ingredient in the Singapore Sling – but not everyone knows that Bénédictine has historical ties with Cognac.

No, Bénédictine is a liqueur and does not contain Cognac. Rather, it is a blend of grape spirits aged in Limousin oak barrels.

Q3. Is Bénédictine the same as brandy?

Bénédictine is a type of brandy, but it is also much more than that. It’s created using a one-of-a-kind blend of herbs and spices that give it a distinct flavor profile.

Brandy, on the other hand, is created by distilling wine.

While both drinks are alcoholic, Bénédictine has a lower ABV (21%) than most types of brandy, some of which can have as high as 50% ABV.

Q4. What liquor is similar to chartreuse?

Liquors are exactly like Chartreuse, but some similar liquors include amaro and Fernet. 

These liquors are all herbal, bitter, and sweet, and they can be enjoyed either on their own or in cocktails. 

If you’re looking for a substitute for Chartreuse, amaro or Fernet is the way to go!

Leave a Comment