Perfecting Crab Cakes: 12 egg substitutes for crab cakes with Ratios & Tips

Crab cakes are one of the most sought-after seafood dishes. With a crispy exterior and a soft, succulent interior, it’s simply irresistible. 

If you have an egg allergy, or you’re vegan or vegetarian? You should take advantage of the goodness of crab cakes.

In this blog post, we’ll share with you 12 egg substitute options for crab cakes with ratios and tips on how to use them. So, let’s dive in!

In short, " What can I use instead of eggs in crab cakes?"

Applesauce, Mashed Bananas, Flaxseed, Silken Tofu, Buttermilk, Yogurt, Aquafaba, Potato Starch, Tofu, Mashed potato, Greek Yogurt, and Mayonnaise.

Best egg substitutes for crab cakes

1. Applesauce – A good egg substitute for crab cakes

applesauce is good egg substitute for crab cakes

Applesauce is a versatile and healthy substitute for eggs in crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: For every egg, you need to mix ¼ cup of unsweetened applesauce.

The texture of the crab cake will be slightly softer, but the flavor will remain the same.

2. Mashed Bananas – similar to an egg for crab cakes

Similar to applesauce, mashed bananas are a great egg substitute alternative for crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: You need to use ¼ cup of mashed ripe banana for every egg.

The flavor will be mild with a subtly sweet aroma.

3. Try Flaxseed instead of egg for crab cakes

flaxseed is good egg alternate for crab cakes

Flaxseed is a great plant-based egg substitute for crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: You need to mix 1 tablespoon of base flaxseed with 3 tablespoons of water for every egg.

This will give you a gooey texture that binds well.

4. Silken Tofu – similar to an egg for crab cakes

Silken tofu makes for a healthy and protein-packed egg substitute for crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: You need to puree ¼ cup of silken tofu for every egg.

This will give you a soft texture with a mild flavor.

5. Buttermilk – a great egg alternative for crab cakes

Buttermilk is a rich and tangy substitute for eggs in crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: You need to mix ¼ cup of buttermilk for every egg.

The texture of the crab cake will be slightly moist with a pronounced tangy flavor.

6. Yogurt – similar to an egg for crab cakes

yoghurt is nice egg alternate for crab cakes

Yoghurt is another tangy substitute for eggs in crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: You need to mix ¼ cup of plain yoghurt for every egg.

The texture of the crab cake will be slightly tangy with a creamy flavor.

7. You can use aquafaba to replace eggs for crab cakes

Aquafaba is a vegan-friendly egg substitute for crab cakes. It is the liquid that comes from canned chickpeas.

Ratio or measurement: You need to whisk 3 tablespoons of aquafaba until foamy for every egg.

This will give you a light, fluffy texture that holds well.

8. Potato Starch – similar to an egg for crab cakes

Potato starch is a gluten-free substitute for eggs in crab cakes.

Ratio or measurement: You need to mix 2 tablespoons of potato starch with 3 tablespoons of water for every egg.

This will give you a firm texture that holds well.

9. Tofu – a decent egg replacement for crab cakes

tofu is excellent egg alternate for crab cakes

Soft tofu mixed with cornflour or arrowroot flour is an excellent substitute for eggs in crab cakes. It will add moisture and help to bind everything together.

Ratio or measurement: Use around ¼ cup of tofu for each egg.

10. Mashed potato – similar to an egg for crab cakes

A mix of mashed potatoes with breadcrumbs and finely chopped celery can make a great substitute for eggs. Mashed potatoes add a unique creamy texture to the cakes and provide a great binding agent.

Ratio or measurement: Use a one-quarter cup of mashed potatoes per egg.

11. Greek Yogurt- a tasty egg substitute for crab cakes

If you want to make healthier crab cakes, use Greek yoghurt as an egg substitute.

Ratio or measurement: Mix ¼ cup of Greek yogurt with one teaspoon of baking powder, and it works like a charm.

It adds a tangy flavor to the crab cakes, so it’s perfect for those who love experimenting with different flavors!

12. Mayonnaise – similar to an egg for crab cakes

mayonnaise is great egg replacement for crab cakes

Another great substitute for eggs in crab cakes is mayonnaise. It’s a creamy and binding ingredient that helps keep everything together.

Ratio or measurement: Use 1/4 cup of mayonnaise for every egg. It also adds a tangy savor to the dish.

What are crab cakes, and what do crab cakes taste like?

Crab cakes are a famous dish in the United States, especially in coastal areas like Maryland and the Chesapeake Bay, where crabs are abundant.

They are essentially a type of fishcake that’s made of crab meat mixed with various other ingredients.

A typical crab cake recipe includes:

– Lump crab meat: This is the primary ingredient and gives the dish its unique flavor and texture.

– Bread crumbs: This help to bind the cake together.

– Mayonnaise, eggs, or both: These are used as a binder and to add moisture.

– Seasonings: These can include mustard, Worcestershire sauce, Old Bay seasoning (a favorite in Maryland), salt, and pepper.

– Fresh herbs: Often parsley or chives, but it could be any herbs that pair well with seafood.

Crab cakes are usually pan-fried, baked, or broiled till they’re golden brown and crispy on the exterior yet remain tender on the inside.

The taste of crab cakes can vary depending on the recipe, but the show’s star is always the crab meat. High-quality crab cakes should have a fresh, sweet, and slightly briny flavor that is distinctly crab.

The additional ingredients add depth to the overall flavor but should never overshadow the crab. The exterior should have a pleasing crunch, which contrasts nicely with the soft, moist interior.

If a sauce is served with the crab cakes, such as a remoulade, aioli, or tartar sauce.

This can add an extra dimension of flavor. But again, a good crab cake doesn’t necessarily need a sauce and should allow the crab flavor to shine through.

Is egg necessary in crab cakes?

Eggs are a common ingredient used in crab cakes as a binder to help keep the cake together. The egg also helps to add flavor and nutrition to the crab cakes.

Additionally, eggs are a source of protein, which can help provide energy to the body and promote fullness after eating. 

While not all recipes for crab cakes call for eggs, they are often included to help bind the ingredients and give the crab cakes a light and fluffy texture.

In addition to using an egg as a binder, some recipes may also include panko bread crumbs or other dry ingredients, such as cracker crumbs, to help keep the crab cakes together.

For those looking for a heartier texture in their crab cakes, adding small cubes of vegetables can also contribute to binding the ingredients together. 

Finally, it is important when making crab cakes to confirm that all ingredients are evenly combined so that the finished product is not too dry or too wet.

With careful consideration and attention given to each ingredient used in a recipe, homemade crab cakes can be an enjoyable treat everyone will love!

Can I make crab cakes without eggs? 

Yes, you can make crab cakes without eggs! To do this, you’ll need to replace the egg with a substitute like unsweetened applesauce or flaxseed meal.

For every egg typically called for in a traditional recipe, replace it with 2 tablespoons of applesauce or 1 tablespoon of flaxseed meal mixed with 3 tablespoons of water.

The applesauce and flaxseed mixture will provide both moisture and binding when mixed together with other ingredients such as breadcrumbs and butter.

This will help ensure that the crab cakes hold their shape when cooked.

Additionally, if desired, ground chia seeds can be used to replace eggs in recipes as they also have great binding properties due to their high mucilage content.

how to bind crab cakes without eggs

Crab cakes are a tasty way to enjoy crab meat, but many recipes call for eggs to help hold the ingredients together.

However, it’s possible to bind crab cakes without eggs by using other binding agents such as mayonnaise, Greek yogurt, or mashed potatoes.

Mayonnaise is an excellent option for binding your crab cakes since it has a creamy texture and contains oil that helps the cakes hold their shape when frying.

To use this method, simply mix 2 tablespoons of mayo with 1 pound of crab meat along with any desired seasonings before forming your patties.

Greek yogurt is another great option for binding crab cakes because it’s high in protein and has enough viscosity to help keep the patties together when cooked.

All you require to do is combine 1/4 cup of Greek yogurt with 1 pound of crab meat and any desired seasoning ingredients before forming into patties.

Mashed potatoes are also a great alternative when making egg-free crab cakes. Potatoes are naturally starchy and will provide enough structure to hold the cake together when cooked.

Start by mashing one large potato and then mixing it with 2 cups of seasoned crab meat before forming into patties.

Making egg-free crab cakes is easy and can be done utilizing one or more of these binding agents, depending on what you have available or prefer.

With patience and practice, anyone can make delicious and perfectly formed egg-free crab cakes that everyone will love!

Best crab cake recipe without egg

Crab cakes are a famous seafood dish that can be enjoyed in various ways. Made with lump crab meat, these tasty bites are usually combined with breadcrumbs, eggs, mayonnaise, and other seasonings for flavor. 

While eggs are indeed an important part of the traditional recipe, it is still possible to make a delicious crab cake without them.

Start by combining fresh lump crab meat with minced celery and onion in a large bowl.

To give the mixture more flavor and texture, stir in some dried herbs such as thyme or oregano, as well as olive oil, lemon juice, garlic powder, and salt to taste.

To bind the ingredients together without using an egg, add some mayonnaise or Greek yogurt until you have reached your desired consistency. 

Finally, fold in breadcrumbs (or crushed crackers) until everything is evenly mixed together.

Form into cakes and cook in a pan over medium-high heat. For best results, use butter or ghee – this will give the patties a golden-brown color while still preserving their delicate texture on the inside.

Serve warm with tartar sauce or your favorite dipping sauce for an irresistible treat! Enjoy!

Tips on How to Choose the Most Suitable substitution Option for eggs in crab cakes

When choosing a suitable substitution option for eggs in crab cakes, consider the following tips:

Purpose of Eggs: Understand the role that eggs play in crab cakes. Eggs act as a binding agent, helping to hold the ingredients together.

Consider the texture and structure that eggs provide and look for a substitute that can fulfill this function.

Similar Binding Agents: Identify other ingredients that can act as binding agents in recipes.

Common substitutes for eggs in binding include mayonnaise, Greek yogurt, mashed avocado, or breadcrumbs mixed with water or milk. These ingredients can help hold the crab cakes together.

Flavor Compatibility: Consider the flavor profile of the substitute. Choose an option that complements the flavors of crab cakes without overpowering the delicate taste of the crab meat.

For example, mayonnaise or Greek yogurt can provide a creamy texture without altering the overall flavor significantly.

Texture Considerations: Pay attention to the texture the substitute will contribute. Eggs add moisture and help maintain the structure of crab cakes.

Look for a substitute that can provide similar moisture and texture, ensuring the crab cakes remain moist and hold their shape during cooking.

Allergies and Dietary Restrictions: Take into account any specific dietary requirements or allergies when selecting a substitute.

For example, if you need an egg-free or vegan option, consider using a commercial egg replacer or flaxseed meal mixed with water.

Recipe Adaptation: Be prepared to adapt your recipe to accommodate the chosen substitute. Consider any adjustments needed in terms of ingredient proportions or cooking times.

Test the substitute in a small batch before making a larger quantity to ensure the desired texture and taste are achieved.

Experimentation and Taste Testing: Experiment with different substitute options and conduct taste tests to determine the best fit for your personal preferences. Make small adjustments as needed to achieve the desired results.

Conclusion on egg substitute for crab cakes

Crab cakes without eggs are still achievable and delicious. 

With these eight egg substitute options for crab cakes with ratios and tips on how to use them, you can enjoy this seafood favorite no matter your dietary restrictions. 

Experiment with these substitutes to find the one that works best for you, and enjoy perfecting crab cakes!

FAQs on egg substitute for crab cakes

Q1. What is similar to eggs as a binder? 

Other ingredients that can be used as binders similar to eggs include chia seeds, flaxseed meal, mashed bananas, mashed potatoes, cornstarch, and even pureed vegetables such as cauliflower or squash.

These alternatives are especially useful for vegan baking recipes that require a binder.

Additionally, there are several commercially available egg replacers that can also be used in place of eggs as a binding agent.

Q2. What can you replace mayo with for crab cakes?

For an alternative to mayonnaise, consider alternatives such as yogurt, sour cream, or avocado. Yogurt can provide a delicious tanginess and creaminess to your crab cakes; just be sure to choose a plain Greek-style yogurt since flavored varieties can be too sweet.

Sour cream also works well as a mayo substitute in crab cakes. It will give the dish a slight acidity that pairs nicely with the other ingredients.

Avocado is another great option for those looking for vegan options–it adds a creamy texture and flavor that pairs nicely with the crab without overpowering it. Plus, avocados are high in fiber and healthy fats, making them a healthier choice than mayonnaise!

Q3. Can you bake with mayo instead of eggs?

Yes, you can bake with mayo instead of eggs. Mayonnaise is made with oil and egg yolks, so it has a similar texture and binding power as eggs in baking recipes.

When substituting for an egg, use 2 tablespoons of mayonnaise per egg in your recipe. Additionally, you can add extra moisture to baked goods by adding 1/4 cup of mayonnaise to the recipe.

However, it’s important to note that using mayonnaise in baking will give the final product a slightly different taste than if you used eggs.

Q4. Can you use mayo instead of eggs for breading?

No, mayonnaise is not a suitable substitute for eggs when it comes to breading. Eggs provide moisture and help bind the bread crumbs or other coating to the food being cooked.

Mayonnaise does not have the same binding properties as eggs, so using it would result in an unsatisfactory final product. Additionally, mayonnaise has a strong taste and smell that can be off-putting in some recipes.

Q5. What keeps crab cakes from falling apart?

Crab cakes are held together by a mixture of ingredients that provide binding, flavor and texture to the cakes. The primary ingredient responsible for keeping them from falling apart is typically breadcrumbs or a combination of breadcrumbs and cracker crumbs.

These act as binders for the other ingredients, such as crab meat, eggs, mayonnaise and seasonings. Additionally, some recipes may call for panko crumbs, cornmeal, or parmesan cheese to also be added to the mix of binding ingredients.

When baking the cakes in an oven or pan-frying them on the stovetop, it is important to confirm that they are cooked all the way through to avoid crumbling when handling them.

To achieve this result, create thick cakes with plenty of butter or oil and cook until golden brown on each side. 

When pan-frying, use a wide skillet with enough oil or butter so that you can turn over the cake without it sticking to the pan or breaking apart.

With either cooking method, transfer your cooked crab cakes carefully onto plates so that they stay intact and don’t lose their shape.

Q6. Is it better to pan-fry or bake crab cakes?

It really depends on the desired result. Baking will yield a more consistent and moist cake, while pan-frying gives it a nice golden color and crunchy outside. Both options can make delicious crab cakes, so it comes down to personal preference.

Q7. What is the best oil to pan-fry crab cakes in?

When it comes to pan-frying crab cakes, the best oil to use is a neutral-flavored oil that can handle high heat. Canola, vegetable, and peanut oil are excellent choices for pan-frying crab cakes.

You like an oil with a high smoke point that won’t burn too quickly; canola and vegetable oils have smoke points of about 400°F, while peanut oil has a higher smoke point of about 450°F.

Additionally, these oils are low in saturated fat – which helps to keep you and your dishes healthy!

When pan-frying your crab cakes, preheat your pan over medium-high heat before adding the oil – this will result in a nice golden brown on the outside while keeping the insides moist and flavorful.

Lastly, don’t be afraid to experiment with other oils like olive or avocado; just make sure that they have similar smoke points as those listed above.

Leave a Comment