13 Best Pepperoncini Substitutes | Similar Heat Alternatives

If you’re looking for a substitute for pepperoncini, there are a few things you can try. Here are some of the best 13 Pepperoncini substitutes for this versatile ingredient.

From simple banana pepper to tabasco pepper, whether you’re looking for something to add to your next dish or just want to try something new, these alternatives will definitely give you what you’re looking for. 

So what are you waiting for? Let’s get started!

What is Pepperoncini?

Pepperoncini is a kind of pepper that is typically used in Italian cuisine. It has slightly fruity with hot chili peppers. 

Pepperoncini can be eaten fresh or pickled. They are available in green and red, but the red pepperoncini are the most commonly used variety.

Pepperoncini can be used in various dishes, including salads, sandwiches, pizzas, and pasta. They are also popular as a condiment and can be added to sauces, dips, and marinades.

What do Pepperoncinis taste like?

Pepperoncinis are a type of pepper that is typically small in size and has a hot and fruity flavor. 

They are commonly used in Italian dishes but can also be enjoyed on their own as a snack. 

Pepperoncinis can be purchased either fresh or canned and are available at most grocery stores.

What can I use in place of pepperoncini? 13 Best Pepperoncini Substitutes

Below are all alternatives for Peperoncino that give you a similar taste that you want; some of them are easy to available all over the year. Some of them present everyone’s kitchen.


If you’re looking for a pepperoncini substitution, you can use banana peppers. Banana peppers are a slightly sweeter alternative to pepperoncini peppers, and they have a similar level of heat. 

banana peppers are a slightly sweeter alternative to pepperoncini peppers.

Banana peppers are also slightly larger than pepperoncini peppers, so they’ll add more flavor and crunch to your dish. 

Try using banana peppers instead of pepperoncini peppers in your favorite recipes, or add them to a salad or sandwiches for some extra flavor and crunch.


Hungarian wax peppers are a type of bell pepper that is long and thin. It has a bit sweet and tangy flavor, making it perfect for substituting pepperoncini in recipes. 

Hungarian wax peppers can be used in both cooked and raw dishes, and they are available year-round. They go well with salads, sandwiches, and tacos.

Hungarian wax peppers can also be stuffed with cheese or meat or used as a topping for pizza. Try using them in this easy recipe for Grilled Cheese and Pepperoncini Sandwiches.


Poblano peppers are a variety of chili pepper that is indigenous to Mexico. It is dark green, about 4-6 inches long and has a slightly sweet, smoky flavor.

Poblanos can be used in many different dishes, either raw or cooked. They are perfect for stuffing with cheese, meat, or rice.

Poblano peppers can also be roasted and used in sauces or Salsas. They are a mild pepper but can be spicy depending on the variety. 

Poblano is a type of pepper similar to a Peperoncino but is smaller and less spicy. In most recipes, they can be used in place of poblanos.


The Trinidad chili pepper can also be used to replace pepperoncini in most recipes.

The Trinidad chili pepper is a type of chili pepper that is named after the Caribbean island nation of Trinidad and Tobago. 

The Trinidad chili pepper is a small, tapered pepper that ranges in color from green to red. The Trinidad chili pepper has a sweet, fruity flavor and is used in many Caribbean dishes.


Another excellent alternative for pepperoncini pepper is Cayenne pepper. It is easy to find and a popular spice used in many dishes.

Cayenne pepper has a spicy, hot flavor that can add excitement to any recipe. If you’re searching for a mode to add some heat to your favorite dish, cayenne pepper is the perfect ingredient.

Cayenne pepper is also a significant way to add some nutritional value to your meal. This spicy pepper is packed with vitamins and minerals, including vitamin A, vitamin C, and potassium. 

So, not only does cayenne pepper add flavor to your dish, but it also provides some nutritional benefits as well.

So next time, whenever you want spicy with nutritious, try cayenne instead. This versatile pepper can go with any recipe.


Another good option for pepperoncino is Cherry pepper. It is a small red pepper with a sweet and slightly spicy flavor. 

cherry pepper is a famous alternative for pepperoncini.

Cherry pepper is often used as a substitute for pepperoncini in recipes. Cherry peppers can be eaten raw or cooked and are most commonly used in salads, appetizers, and main dishes. 

They are available fresh or canned and can be found in most grocery stores.


When most people think of Anaheim peppers, they think of the famous chili pepper that is typically used in Mexican cuisine. 

However, Anaheim peppers can also be used as a substitute for pepperoncini in recipes.

Anaheim peppers have a sweet and slightly spicy flavor that can add a kick to your dish. They are also relatively mild, making them a good choice for those who are not fans of spicy food.

If you are looking for a way to add some spice to your dish, consider using Anaheim peppers instead of pepperoncini. 

You can use Anaheim in recipes like fajitas, tacos, and salads. They will add a touch of flavor and heat to your dish without being too spicy.

So next time you’re searching for a way to spice up your food, consider using Anaheim peppers in place of pepperoncini. 

You’ll be amazed how nicely they work in various recipes. You’ll also have the extra benefit of consuming some healthful antioxidants.


Tabasco pepper is a hot pepper that is named after the Mexican state of Tabasco. It is a small, thin chili pepper about 2-3 inches long and has a thin, pointy tail. 

The Tabasco pepper packs a lot of heat and has a fruity, acidic flavor. It is typically used to add heat to dishes but can also be used in moderation to add flavor.

One of my favorite practices to use Tabasco pepper is in place of pepperoncini in recipes. Pepperoncini are small, sweet peppers that are typically used in salads or as a topping on sandwiches. 

They have a mild flavor and a slightly sweet/tart taste. I like to use Tabasco pepper instead because it has more heat and adds a nice kick to dishes.

If you are looking for a way to add some heat to your next recipe, give Tabasco pepper a try! It can be used in place of other hot peppers or simply added to dishes for a bit of extra heat. Enjoy!

Check Out- The Best Tabasco Sauce alternatives are already in your kitchen.


The jalapeno pepper is a type of chili pepper typically green in color and has a moderate heat level. Jalapeno peppers are a popular ingredient in spicy Mexican dishes. They can also be used in salads, salsas, and condiments. 

In recipes, jalapeno peppers are often used to add spice to dishes and can be replaced for pepperoncini.

Most important, you can add Jalapeno peppers as fresh to dishes, or they can be roasted or pickled. 


Friggitello is a type of pepper similar to pepperoncini but has a slightly different flavor. You can use it as a substitute for pepperoncini in most recipes. 

Friggitello peppers are usually pickled and sold in jars or cans. They also can be eaten raw and are occasionally used in salads.


Cubanelle peppers are sweet pepper similar in size and shape to the bell pepper. They have thin skin and a slightly sweet flavor. 

Cubanelle peppers are most commonly used in Italian cuisine, where they are often substituted for pepperoncini peppers. 

They can be added to salads, sauces, or dishes like pizza or pasta.

Cubanelle peppers are available year-round and can be found in most grocery stores. They’re a valuable source of vitamin C and potassium.

Check Out-Best Cubanelle Peppers Substitutes


Red pepper flakes are a fantastic method to add heat and flavor to recipes. 

They can be used in place of pepperoncini in most recipes, and they also work well in marinades and dressings. 

Red pepper flakes are available at most grocery stores, and they can be stored in a pantry or wardrobe for up to six months.

When using red pepper flakes in a recipe, it’s essential to start with a small amount and add more as needed. This will assist to keep the meal from being overly spicy.

Red pepper flakes can be used in both cooked and uncooked dishes and they are a great way to add flavor to simple recipes.

Read More- Best Guajillo Chili Substitutes

Pepperoncini substitute Mississippi roast

One of the best ways to enjoy a Mississippi roast is to use pepperoncini as a substitute. Pepperoncini are small, green peppers with a slightly sweet and spicy flavor. 

They can be seen in most grocery stores, and they are a great way to add extra flavor to your roast. 

\If you don’t have pepperoncini available, you can also use other types of peppers, such as jalapeños or banana peppers. 

Just remove the seeds before using them, as they will add extra heat to your dish.

Another amazing way to add flavor to your roast is to use a variety of spices. Try using garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and black pepper. These spices will give your roast a delicious flavor that everyone will love.

So, if you’re glancing for a new and exciting way to prepare a roast, consider using pepperoncini as a substitute. You’ll be stunned at how delicious it is!

Read More- Ancho Chili Powder Alternatives

Pickled pepperoncini substitute

If you can’t find pickled pepperoncini, or if you’re looking for a substitute, there are a few options. You could use any pickled pepper, such as 

  • · banana peppers, 
  • · jalapeños, or 
  • · even green bell peppers. 

Another choice is to make your own pickled pepperoncini. 

All you need is some vinegar, water, sugar, and salt, and you can use any type of pepper you like. Finally, if you’re looking for a

completely different flavor, you could try using marinated artichoke hearts as a substitute.

They have a slightly sour and salty flavor that goes well with pepperoncini. No matter what substitute you choose, you’re sure to enjoy the tangy flavor of pickled pepperoncini.

Dried pepperoncini substitute

You can use a few substitutes for Dried pepperoncini if you don’t have any on hand. 

· One option is banana peppers, which have a similar flavor. 

· Another option is jalapeño peppers, which have a slightly spicier flavor. 

· If you’re looking for a milder substitution, try using sweet bell peppers instead. Whichever substitute you choose, make sure to chop them up into small pieces to make them easy to eat.

Finally, if you really don’t have any other option, you can leave the pepperoncini out of the recipe altogether. This may not be the perfect solution, but it will taste delicious!

Wrap Up on Substitute for Pepperoncini Peppers

Pepperoncini peppers are a fabulous addition to any dish. They have a sharp, spicy taste that can add flavor to any meal. 

Suppose you can’t find them at your local grocery store. In that case, they can be substituted with other types of peppers mentioned above.

FAQs Related To Pepperoncino Peppers and its Alternatives 

Q1. What’s similar to pepperoncini?

While pepperoncini are spicy, they’re not as spicy as other peppers like Friggitello, Banana, Poblano, and jalapeno peppers. 

They’ve a barely sweet taste and a tangy flavor. This makes them perfect for adding to salads, pickles, sandwiches, and pizzas.

Q2. Can you use jalapenos instead of pepperoncini?

Yes, you can use jalapenos instead of pepperoncini. Jalapeno peppers are a little spicier than pepperoncini peppers, so you may want to use less if you’re not used to spicy foods. 

However, jalapeno peppers are an excellent substitute for
pepperoncini peppers in most recipes.

Q3. Is Hot chili peppers the same as pepperoncini?

The response to this question is yes – Hot chili peppers and pepperoncini are both types of peppers. 

Although hot Chili peppers are typically more desirable than pepperoncini, there can be some variation in heat levels depending on the variety of pepper. 

Both hot chili peppers and pepperoncini are used in cooking, and they can be added to dishes for flavor or heat. 

Pepperoncini are also sometimes used as a pickled pepper.
They can be eaten on their own or added to sandwiches or salads.

Q4. What do pepperoncini peppers look like?

Pepperoncini peppers are small, thin, and slightly curved. They typically have a green color but can also be red or yellow. They are about 2-3 inches long and have a sharp taste.

Leave a Comment