9+ top best substitutes for sport pepper & way to use @2023

Sport peppers are a unique type of pepper used in many dishes. They are small and quite spicy, which makes them a great addition to salads, sandwiches, and other recipes.

Unfortunately, these peppers can be hard to find sometimes. If you can’t find sports peppers for your recipe, don’t worry!

There are some great substitutes that will work just as well. Let’s explore the options so you can find the perfect substitute for sports peppers in your dish.

What kind of pepper is a sport pepper? What does Sport pepper taste like?

A sport pepper is a type of small chili pepper, usually measuring about two inches in length. It is derived from a variety of jalapeno peppers and has a heat level that ranges from mild to hot, depending on the variety.

The flavor of the sport pepper is similar to that of its parent pepper; it is robust and slightly sweet, with a hint of smokiness. 

What does Sport peppers use in recipes and cooking

Sport peppers are commonly used in the cuisines of the American Southern and Southwestern regions.

It is best used in Chicago-style Hot dogs and also often pickled or served raw as a condiment for dishes such as hamburgers, sandwiches, salads, and tacos.

Additionally, they can also be ground into powders or used to flavor chili and other savory dishes. The sport pepper is a popular garnish for Mexican foods, such as tacos and nachos.

They are also commonly used in Latin American cuisine, such as ceviche and guacamole.

In the United States, they can often be found pickled in jars or cans at many supermarkets. While they may be used as a condiment, they can also be eaten alone and enjoyed for their flavor and mild heat.

Pickled sport peppers are often served on the side of dishes or sandwiches to add a bit of heat and flavor.

They can also be chopped up and added to sauces, marinades, soups, or used as a topping on sandwiches and burgers.

They can also be added to salsa or guacamole for extra flavor and heat. The sport pepper is an excellent addition to many recipes, adding a unique depth of flavor that many other peppers cannot match.

Where to buy sports peppers?

Sport peppers can be purchased at many supermarkets, specialty stores, and online retailers. Depending on your location in the US, you may find them canned or jarred in the condiment aisle of most major grocery stores.

If you’re looking for a more unique variety, head to a specialty store like Whole Foods or The Spice House.

You can also order sport peppers online from retailers like Amazon or Gourmet Food Store.

No matter where you decide to shop, make sure that the peppers are fresh and of good quality before purchasing.

Why is it called a sport pepper?

The term “sport pepper” is believed to have originated in the early 1900s with patrons of Chicago hot dog stands.

It was a tradition for customers to ask for an extra spicy version of their hot dogs, which were topped with an additional pickled pepper known as the sport pepper.

The name comes from its association with the city’s many sporting events and teams. 

Best Substitute for Sport Peppers

Sport peppers are usually a combination of serrano chili peppers and cayenne peppers.

Fortunately, there are plenty of other options out there that will give you the same flavor without having to buy a special pepper.

Here are some great substitutes for sport peppers:

1. Pickled serrano peppers

Pickled serrano peppers are becoming an increasingly popular choice when it comes to replacing sport peppers in cooking.

Not only do they offer a similar flavor, but they provide an extra layer of tartness that adds zest and zing to any recipe.

This makes them suitable for use in sauces, soups, and other dishes where the extra flavor is desired, but heat needs to be kept in check.

Additionally, the pickling process enhances their flavor profile even more – adding notes of vinegar, garlic, cloves, herbs, and spices that really elevate the taste of whatever it is added to.

pickled serrano pepper is a good substitute for sport pepper

Serranos also provide a decent amount of heat without being too overpowering, making them a great option for those looking for just a bit of extra flavor with their meals.

Pickled serrano peppers can last for long periods of time in the fridge, so there is less worry about having to constantly buy fresh sports peppers, which may be hard to come by for many people.

Eating pickled serranos can give your food a delightful twist that you won’t soon forget!

2. Pickled jalapeño peppers

Jalapeños are another popular pepper variety that is often used as a substitute for sport peppers. They have a similar flavor to sport peppers but with less heat.

Jalapeños are another popular pepper variety that is often used as a substitute for sport peppers.
Pickled jalapeño peppers

They can be used as a one-to-one substitution in most recipes that call for sport peppers.

Although they tend to be larger than sport peppers, they can be cut into smaller pieces that mimic their size and shape.

The flavor is somewhat different; jalapeños tend to be spicier than sport peppers but also have an earthy sweetness to them that many people enjoy.

 Just like with banana peppers, you may need to use more jalapeños than you normally would with sports pepper in order to get the same level of spice in your dish.

3. Turkish Pickled Peppers

If you are a fan of spicy food and looking for a substitute for sport peppers, Turkish Pickled Peppers are a perfect choice.

They are made from bell peppers that have been smoked, pickled, and spiced with natural ingredients such as salt, garlic, oregano, and black pepper.

Their flavor is deliciously smoky and tangy with a nice kick which makes them a great alternative to sport peppers.

They are great for adding a kick to fish dishes, salads, or vegetables but can also be used as the star ingredient in an eggplant dip such as baba ganoush.

Best of all, these tasty treats last for months in the refrigerator so you don’t need to worry about stocking up if you want to enjoy them regularly.

Try adding Turkish Pickled Peppers to your next sandwich or taco and you will be pleasantly surprised at how they amp up the dish’s flavor.

4. Chipotle peppers Close to Jalapenos

If you are looking for a smoky, fiery flavor than the zesty kick of sport peppers, try subbing Chipotle peppers.

If you are looking for a smoky, fiery flavor than the zesty kick of sport peppers, try subbing Chipotle peppers.
Chipotle peppers

Although chipotle peppers come from the same family as jalapenos, they tend to be much smokier and full-bodied in flavor due to the additional smoke-drying process that goes into making them.

The perfect replacement for dishes that call for a medium heat level with plenty of flavors, these amazing peppers pack enough heat to make your palate sizzle without being too overpowering.

With its wonderful blend of each chili pepper’s unique characteristics, Chipotle peppers will be an excellent addition to your favorite dish.

5. Pickled pepperoncini

If you love spicy, pickled peppers but don’t have access to sport peppers, then pepperoncini are a tasty substitute.

If you love spicy, pickled peppers but don't have access to sport peppers, then pepperoncini are a tasty substitute.
Pickled pepperoncini

These mild Italian peppers offer a number of culinary delights when pickled, such as adding pizzazz to sandwiches and salads.

Perhaps their best use is as an addition to Italian dishes like pizza, lasagna, and spaghetti, where they add texture and that extra zip of flavor.

Pepperoncini come in various sizes depending on the variety and the preference of the chef; larger ones tend to be milder while the smallish ones pack more punch.

No matter which one you prefer, you will get an array of peppery flavors that bring new life to your favorite dishes.

6. Pickled banana peppers

If you are searching for a delicious and unique substitution for sport pepper, look no further than pickled banana peppers!

These delightful treats pack a punch of flavor with a mild kick of heat.

The taste is slightly sweet, while the texture is crisp and crunchy. Pickled banana peppers pair beautifully with so many dishes, from pizza to salads to sandwiches. 

They will bring an extra layer of flavor and spice that will take your meal’s flavor profile to the next level.

If you want something out-of-the-ordinary, adding pickled banana peppers as a substitute for sport pepper will do the trick!

7. Peppadew 

If you’re looking for something milder than any of these options, try using Peppadews instead! These mild sweet pickled chilis offer just enough flavor and sweetness to add interest to your dishes without too much heat.

If you're looking for something milder than any of these options, try using Peppadews instead!

If you’re a fan of adding some kick to your meals, Peppadew is an exciting substitute for the classic sport pepper.

Similar in flavor but much sweeter, these mini-peppers are a great way to add a little zing without overwhelming the dish.

They can be added straight into dishes or used as an element of marinades and sauces, bringing a unique complexity and brightness to whichever dish they are included in. 

If you’re looking for something different than traditional sport peppers, give Peppadew a try – you won’t be disappointed!

8. Cherry Bombs 

Cherry bombs are another great option for substituting for sport peppers if you can’t find any at your local grocer or farmer’s market.

They’re similar in size and shape but tend to be much spicier than either banana or jalapeño peppers.

As such, it’s important not to add too many cherry bombs to your recipe unless you really like things spicy!

But if that’s what you’re going for, then cherry bombs make an excellent choice when it comes time to replace the missing sports pepper ingredient from your dish.

The cherry bomb pepper is another great option if you need something with more heat than jalapeno or habanero peppers.

These small red chilis pack quite a bit of heat and have sweet undertones that make them ideal for adding flavor to your dishes without overpowering them.

9. Guajillo chili

If you’re searching for a way to spice up your cooking but are out of sport peppers, consider using Guajillo chili as an alternative.

The mild-medium heat profile of the Guajillo chili is the closest approximation to sport peppers, without having the typical sharp bite they tend to bring.

guajillo chili is a good alternative for sport pepper

A sprinkle of ground powder or a few slices gives dishes just the added zing they need without overpowering the flavors already present in the dish.

You’ll find it easy to work with in recipes now that you’ve got the perfect substitute for sport peppers!

10. Pickled green chili

If you have a recipe that calls for sport pepper but can’t seem to find it anywhere, don’t sweat. Pickled green chili is an excellent substitution!

This unique pepper is pickled with a special blend of herbs and spices, giving it an exotic spicy flavor that works perfectly in any dish that calls for sport peppers.

It’s also quite versatile, so you can use it as an inclusion in salads, sandwiches, and even salsas.

So if you’re looking to cook something flavorful and are in a pinch, opt for pickled green chili to kick up the heat – you won’t be disappointed!

Conclusion on substitute for sport pepper

There are plenty of great substitutes for sport peppers available, so you don’t have to miss out on all the delicious flavors they bring!

Whether you prefer something milder like jalapeno or habanero peppers or something spicier like chipotle in adobo sauce or cherry bomb pepper, there’s sure to be an option that fits your taste preferences perfectly!

So the next time you’re making a dish that calls for sport peppers but doesn’t have access to them, don’t worry—just reach into your pantry and find one of these amazing substitutes instead!

FAQs on substitute for sport pepper

Q1. Are sport peppers jalapenos?

Sport peppers are a variety of pepper that is commonly used as a condiment, typically served over hotdogs in the Chicago area. They look similar to jalapeno peppers but have a very different flavor. Sport peppers are generally much milder than jalapeños, with some varieties having no heat at all.

The texture of sport peppers is slightly softer and contains a sweet taste, while jalapeno peppers tend to be much hotter and offer an acidic flavor. Overall, despite their similarities in appearance, sport peppers and jalapenos are two distinct types of chili pepper that vary greatly in taste and heat level.

Q2. How to make sport peppers?

Making sport peppers is actually quite simple. All you’ll need to get started is some jalapeño peppers, a jar with a lid, and some vinegar. Once you have those, simply cut up the peppers into slices or cubes of your desired size, then put them into the jar with vinegar until it’s full.

After it’s all been filled up, screw the lid on tightly and let the mixture sit for at least a week before use. Once they’re ready to eat, they can be added to just about any dish that needs an extra kick! With their vibrant flavor and mild spiciness, these flavorful little creations will give your meals that unmistakable spice that’ll keep you coming back for more.

Leave a Comment