13 Best substitutes for Monterey jack cheese | Easy & Cheap

If you love Mexican food as much as I do. The only thing keeping you from enjoying your favorite dishes is most likely a lack of an ingredient.

Monterey jack cheese can be hard to come by for those who live in rural areas or just want a break from their usual grocery list. 

Luckily, there are many substitutes for Monterey jack cheese which will allow you to enjoy your favorite dishes without worrying about finding the right ingredients. 

Today I will provide some ideas on how to substitute different cheeses so that your recipe doesn’t have any problems because These cheeses have similar textures and flavors to your favorite Monterey jack cheese!

13 substitutes for Monterey jack cheese

1. EDAM CHEESE – Healthy Replacement for Monterey Jack Cheese

Edam cheese is a semi-hard cheese best alternative to Monterey Jack Cheese made from pasteurized cow’s milk. It has a mild flavor and a firm texture. 

Edam cheese is a semi-hard cheese best alternative to Monterey Jack Cheese

Edam cheese is often used in dishes such as quesadillas, pizzas, and fondues.

Edam cheese can be purchased at most grocery stores. It is available in both shredded and sliced forms. 

Edam cheese can also be frozen, so you can keep it on hand for quick and easy meals. It is also a good source of calcium and vitamin A. 

Edam cheese is a healthy choice for people looking for low-fat, high-protein food and lactose intolerant. 

2. PARMESAN CHEESE – A Easy Monterey Jack Cheese Substitution

Parmesan cheese is a hard, dry cheese with a very strong flavor made from cow’s milk. The cheese is named after the Italian city of Parma. 

PARMESAN CHEESE - A Easy Monterey Jack Cheese Substitution

Parmesan cheese is one of the most popular cheeses in the world. It is used in many dishes, including pasta dishes, pizza, and salads.

Read More- Try These Parmesan Rind Alternatives, You’ll Amazed


cheddar cheese is a famous substitute for monterey jack cheese

Cheddar’s flavor is much creamier and more pronounced than Monterey jack’s. 

Cheddar cheese is a hard cheese with a creamy and pronounced flavor. It is made from cow’s milk and has a slightly sharp taste. 

Cheddar cheese can be used in many different dishes, such as macaroni and cheese, quesadillas, or pizza.

4. Try DRIED MOZZARELLA Instead of Monterey Jack Cheese

Another popular variety of mozzarella used instead of Monterey jack cheese is the dried mozzarella. 

Dried mozzarella cheese is made by draining the whey from mozzarella curds and then shaping the curds into a ball. 

Dried mozzarella cheese balls are then hung in a warm, humid room to allow them to dry. 

Once they have dried, they are often coated in a mixture of oil, salt, and pepper. 

In many cases, after the cheese has dried, it is then aged for several months in a cool environment to further develop the flavor.

5. Use COLBY CHEESE Place of Monterey Jack Cheese for Slicing

Colby cheese is made from cow’s milk, and both have a mild flavor. Colby a good choice for slicing or shredding.

COLBY CHEESE Place of Monterey Jack Cheese for Slicing

Colby has a richer flavor and creamier texture.

6. MUENSTER CHEESE A Good Alternative for Monterey Jack Cheese

Muenster cheese was initially developed in Munster, located in French Alsace-Lorraine (an area long contested between France and Germany).

Muenster cheese is a type of cheese made in the United States. It is a semi-soft, unripened cheese with a mild, slightly sweet flavor. 

Muenster cheese is an excellent alternative to Monterey jack cheese, a semi-soft, unripened cheese. 

However, Monterey jack cheese has a more robust flavor than muenster cheese. 

Monterey jack cheese is the most popular type of cheese in the United States, making up about 30% of all cheeses produced.


Swiss cheese is a versatile food that can be enjoyed in various ways. It can be eaten on its own as a snack or added to sandwiches, salads, and other dishes. 

SWISS CHEESE is an alternative to Monterey Jack Cheese

Swiss Cheese is also a great addition to appetizers and party platters.

So next time you are looking for a healthy and delicious snack or dish to enjoy, consider adding Swiss cheese to the menu. 

You will not only be satisfying your taste buds, but you will also be doing your body a favor.


If you are looking for something different to try for dinner or an appetizer at your next party, consider using Younger Gouda cheese. 

Younger Gouda cheese is a type of Gouda cheese made from the milk of cows that are less than 12 months old. 

The cheese has a milder flavor and a softer texture than traditional Gouda cheese. 

Younger Gouda cheese can be used in various dishes, including pasta dishes, salads, and appetizers. It can also be eaten on its own as a snack. 

Younger Gouda cheese is available at most grocery stores.

If you are searching for a mild, creamy cheese to add to your next dish, consider using Younger Gouda cheese. It is sure to please your taste buds!

9. HAVARTI CHEESE Popular Substitute for Monterey Jack Cheese

There are often many different ways to make the same dish when it comes to cooking and recipes. -This is also the case with cheese. 

havarti cheese is semi-soft in nature and a good alternative for Monterey jack cheese

While Monterey jack cheese is a common choice for recipes, Havarti cheese can also be a great alternative.

Havarti is a semi-soft, creamy cheese that has a mild flavor. It goes well in dishes where you crave the cheese to be the star of the show, such as in quesadillas or macaroni and cheese.

Havarti also melts well, so it is perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches or pizza.

If you are looking for a change from Monterey jack, try Havarti cheese the next time you cook some cheese-centric dishes. 

You may be surprised at how great it tastes!

10. PROVOLONE – A Decent Monterey Jack Cheese Substitute

There are a variety of cheese alternatives you can use when making your favorite quesadilla recipes. 

If you want a mildly different flavor, try using provolone cheese instead of Monterey jack cheese. 

Provolone is a mild Italian cheese that pairs well with savory and sweet toppings. Plus, it’s a great way to add some healthy protein to your meal. 

Give it a try the next time you’re in the mood for quesadillas!

Some other great cheese alternatives include cheddar, brie, and feta. 

Experiment with various mixtures to discover your favorite flavor profile. 

And don’t forget the salsa and guacamole – they’re essential for any good quesadilla recipe.

11. YOUNG GRUYERE – Similar to Monterey jack Cheese

While Monterey jack cheese is an excellent option for many dishes, it can be expensive and difficult to find in some areas. 

A good Gruyere alternative is Young Gruyere cheese. This cheese has a similar flavor and texture to Monterey jack. Still, it is much more affordable and easier to find. 

Young Gruyere can be used in most dishes that call for Monterey jack cheese, including quesadillas, enchiladas, and tacos.

If you are looking for an affordable and versatile cheese option, Young Gruyere is a great choice. 

Young Gruyere can be used in both savory and sweet dishes, and it pairs well with a variety of different flavors. 

Try using Young Gruyere in place of Monterey jack cheese in your next recipe, and you won’t be disappointed.

12. EMMENTHAL High Protein Alternative to Monterey Jack Cheese

Emmenthal cheese is a Swiss cheese that can be used as a substitute for Monterey jack cheese in recipes. 

Emmenthal has a similar flavor and texture to Monterey jack, so it’s a good option if you’re looking for an alternative. 

Emmenthal is also a good choice for high-protein cheese. It has more protein than Monterey jack, so it can help you meet your daily protein goals.

Emmenthal Drives you some excitement for your meals, so try using Emmenthal instead of Monterey jack cheese. You may be amazed at how great it tastes!

13. COMTE 

Comté cheese is a famous French cheese made from unpasteurized cow’s milk. It has a firm texture and a nutty, earthy flavor.

Comté cheese is a versatile cheese that can be used in savory and sweet dishes. It is often used in onion soup, quiche, and fondue dishes. 

Comté cheese can also be used to make dessert recipes such as crepes and tarts.

This French cheese will add flavor and depth to your dishes. Experiment with different recipes and see how comté cheese can make a difference in your cooking.

Read More- some Vegan alternatives for Monetery Jack Cheese

What is Monterey Jack cheese similar to?

Monterey Jack is a mild white melting cheese. It’s similar to Colby and mozzarella cheeses because they are all part of the “American Cheese” family.

Which isn’t so much a single type of cheese as it is a group of cheeses that include many cousins. 

Cheddar and provolone cheeses also fall under this family, so Monterey Jack shares similarities with those cheeses as well. 

All these American cheeses were originally created by early settlers in America who used whatever ingredients they had available locally to make them. 

Over time, different cultures started making these cheeses in different regions with local variations, resulting in the many kinds of American cheese today. 

Monterey Jack is most commonly used in dishes like quesadillas, enchiladas, and burritos. It also goes great as a topping on burgers or steaks. 

Try it out for yourself and see how you like it!

Can you substitute mozzarella for Monterey Jack cheese?

Yes. You Can Substitute Mozzarella for Monterey Jack Cheese. Mozzarella has a more robust flavor and perhaps a slightly grainy texture.

However, these two kinds of cheese both share many of the same ingredients: milk, sodium citrate (for melting), salt, microbial (non-animal) rennet, and enzymes (used instead of animal rennet).

What is the difference between mozzarella and Monterey Jack cheese?

The differentiating factor between mozzarella and Monterey Jack is the moisture content. 

Mozzarella has a slightly higher moisture content than Monterey Jack which means that less rennet is required to produce curds from either type of milk than would be needed with lower moisture cheeses such as cheddar or Parmesan. 

Consequently, the flavor of Monterey Jack may be slightly more pronounced than mozzarella. 

If you are looking for a cheese that will melt well and has a mild flavor, Monterey Jack is a good choice. 

If you are looking for a cheese with a stronger flavor and perhaps a slightly grainy texture, mozzarella would be a better option.

My All Time Favourite Monterey Jack Substitutes

  • Parmesan
  • Chedder
  • Comte
  • Emmenthal
  • Muenster cheese
  • Young Gruyere
  • Provolone
  • Swiss Cheese

Wrap Up on- Monterey Jack Cheese Substitutes

A comprehensive list of cheese substitutes that are vegan and vegetarian, along with a brief description. 

Every major food group is covered: dairy, eggs, soy-based products, nuts/seeds/legumes, gluten-free options. 

The main goal for this information is to provide you with a resource so you can substitute your favorite cheeses easily in any recipe or meal without breaking the bank or compromising flavor. 

We hope these suggestions will inspire creativity in cooking and lead us into a healthier lifestyle while still enjoying our favorite dishes!

Don’t Miss- Top Basket Cheese Substitutes– Easy & Cheap

FAQs – Alternatives to Monterey Jack Cheese

Q1. Is Monterey Jack cheese similar to provolone?

Monterey Jack cheese is similar to provolone in that they are both semi-soft cheeses. 

However, Monterey Jack has a milder flavor than provolone. 
Additionally, Monterey Jack tends to be less salty than provolone. 

So, if you’re looking for a mild cheese with a slightly salty flavor, Monterey Jack is a good option. 

If you want a strong cheese with a sharper flavor, provolone is the better choice.

Q2. What can I use if I don’t have Monterey Jack cheese?

You can use a few different options if you don’t have Monterey Jack cheese. 

You could use cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, or brie cheese. 
These cheeses would be great substitutes for Monterey Jack cheese in most recipes.

One more option is to use a mixture of different types of cheese.

For example, you could use cheddar cheese and Parmesan cheese, or brie cheese and blue cheese. 

This will give your dish a slightly different flavor than using Monterey Jack cheese.

Q3. Is Monterey Jack the same as pepper jack?

Monterey Jack cheese is also known as pepper Jack, and both kinds of cheese are produced in the same way. 

Pepper jack is simply Monterey Jack with added spice (usually jalapeno peppers).

Q4. What is the UK equivalent of Monterey Jack cheese?

Cheddar cheese is a hard, cow’s milk cheese that is popular in the United Kingdom. It has a sharp, pungent flavor and is usually eaten as part of a meal or as a snack. 

Cheddar cheese can be applied in recipes or melted on toast. Some people also enjoy it with pickles or chutney.

Q5. Australian substitute for Monterey jack cheese?

These 3 Australian Substitutes for Monterey Jack Cheese are Perfect and similar to it.

Gippsland Blue is an Australian cheese made from cow’s milk, has creamy sweet with tangy flavor.
Roaring Forties Blue is an Australian cheese made from pasteurized cow’s milk, has a sweet yet fruity flavor. It is similar to Monterey Jack Cheese.
Duet is another Australian cheese made from cow’s and goat milk, has a mild flavor like Monterey Jack cheese. Although, More tangy than Monterey Jack.

Leave a Comment