14 Best Sugar Free Substitutes for Corn Syrup with Ratio & How to Use the Alternatives

As a home cook and chef, I have always been interested in finding alternatives to the traditional ingredients in my cooking and baking recipes.

This involves using substitutes that cater to specific dietary needs, like sugar-free, gluten-free, or vegan alternatives. This post is all about the best sugar-free substitutes for corn syrup.

Corn syrup is used in many recipes to give it sweetness and improve texture, but it also has negative effects on our health, like raising blood sugar levels.

In this post, I will talk about 14 sugar free substitutes for corn syrup, calculate the ratios, and provide tips on using each alternative.

In short, "What can I use instead of corn syrup?"

Agave syrup, Honey, Maple syrup, Brown rice syrup, Coconut nectar, Molasses, Date syrup, Stevia, Fruit Purees, Applesauce, Banana Puree, Date Paste, Yacon Syrup, and Fruit concentrate.

What is corn syrup, and what does corn syrup taste like?

Corn syrup is a dense, sweet syrup created from cornstarch. It is generally used as a sweetener and a binder in various food products and recipes.

Corn syrup is created through a process that breaks down cornstarch into simple sugars, primarily glucose, which gives it its sweet taste.

In terms of flavor, corn syrup has a mild and subtle sweetness. 

It is not as intensely sweet as some other sweeteners like table sugar or honey. The taste of corn syrup can be described as clean and neutral, allowing it to blend well with other flavors without overpowering them.

It lacks distinct flavor notes and doesn’t have the same depth or complexity as some natural sweeteners.

It’s necessary to note that there are various types of corn syrup, including light corn syrup and dark corn syrup. 

Light corn syrup is transparent and has a milder flavor, while dark corn syrup has a deeper color and a stronger, more caramel-like taste.

Overall, corn syrup provides sweetness and viscosity to recipes without adding a distinctive flavor of its own.

Its primary role is to enhance other ingredients and help maintain the texture and consistency of various food products.

Uses of corn syrup

Corn syrup is a sweetener from corn and is widely used in food production. It is typically made by breaking down the starches of corn into simple sugars, which are then processed to create a thick syrup.

This syrup is often used as an alternative to sugar in many sweet foods, such as candy, cookies, sundaes, cakes and other desserts.

Corn syrup is also used as an ingredient in various sauces and in products like jams, jellies, and preserves.

Its use allows for better control of sweetness levels while providing a glossy appearance to finished products.

In addition, it can use to thicken foods or keep them from crystallizing.

In drinks that require carbonation, corn syrup can be used to add sweetness without using sugar or artificial sweeteners. 

It also helps prevent foam formation during fermentation and aging processes.

Corn syrup contains mostly glucose molecules with very few fructose molecules compared with high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS).

Unlike HFCS, it does not contain any enzymes and cannot be further broken down into simpler carbohydrates during digestion. Corn syrup has fewer calories than table sugar but more than honey.

Where to buy corn syrup?

If you are looking for corn syrup where to buy, there are a few other places you can go. Many specialty food stores carry it, as do some international grocery stores

You can also order online from many retailers that provide a variety of diverse flavors and types of corn syrup.

Best sugar-free substitutes for corn syrup with a ratio

1. Agave syrup – A great sugar-free substitute for corn syrup

Agave syrup is obtained from the leaves of the agave plantIt is sweeter than corn syrup with a similar texture and viscosity.

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for agave syrup as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1, meaning you can use the same amount of agave syrup as the corn syrup in your recipe.

However, it is essential to remember that agave syrup is high in fructose and may not be suitable for people with fructose malabsorption.

2. Honey

honey is great sugar free substitute for corn syrup

Honey is a natural sweetener used in many sweet and savory dishes. It is sweeter than corn syrup and has a thicker consistency.

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for honey as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1, meaning you can utilize the same amount of honey as the corn syrup in your recipe.

However, honey has a distinct flavor that may change the taste of your recipe.

3. Try Maple syrup to replace corn syrup

Maple syrup is a popular natural sweetener derived from the sap of maple trees. It has an uncommon flavor and is often used in baking recipes like pancakes and waffles.

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for maple syrup as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1.25, which means that you need to use 25% more maple syrup than corn syrup in your recipe.

4. Brown rice syrup

Brown rice syrup is a sweetener extracted from cooked brown riceIt has a mild savor and is not as sweet as corn syrup. 

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for brown rice syrup as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1.25, which means that you need to use 25% more brown rice syrup than corn syrup in your recipe.

5. Coconut nectar – A tasty sugar-free alternative to corn syrup

coconut nectar is good sugar free alternate for corn syrup

Coconut nectar is a low-glycemic sweetener extracted from the sap of coconut trees. It has a rich savor and is perfect for use in baking recipes.

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for coconut nectar as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1, meaning you can use the same amount of coconut nectar as corn syrup in your recipe.

Discover more: Best substitutes for Coconut flakes

6. Molasses

Molasses is a byproduct of sugar production that has a distinct flavor. It is not sweet like corn syrup and has a thick, viscous texture.

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for molasses as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1.33, which means that you need to use 33% more molasses than corn syrup in your recipe.

7. You can use Date syrup instead of corn syrup

Date syrup is a sweetener created from dates that has a caramel-like flavor. It is perfect for use in baking bread and pastries. 

Ratio or measurement: The ratio for date syrup as a corn syrup substitute is 1:1.33, which means that you need to use 33% more date syrup than corn syrup in your recipe.

8. Stevia

stevia is nice sugar free replacement for corn syrup

Stevia is an all-natural, zero-calorie sweetener perfect for those who want to avoid sugar and excess calories.

This is 200-300 times sweeter than sugar and is available in liquid and granulated form.

Ratio or measurement: To substitute one cup of corn syrup with stevia, mix one teaspoon of stevia with 1/3 cup of water or yogurt, and use accordingly.

9. Fruit Purees – A great sugar-free replacement for corn syrup

Fruit purees are an excellent alternative to corn syrup and can add a unique flavor to your dish. You can use applesauce, mashed bananas, or pureed strawberries as a substitute for corn syrup.

Ratio or measurement: To substitute one cup of corn syrup, use 2/3 cup of fruit puree and 1/3 cup of water.

10. Applesauce

This is a great all-natural solution that can be used as a sugar-free replacement for corn syrup.

Applesauce has little to no natural sugar and adds a small amount of sweetness without the calories or health implications of traditional sugars.

Ratio or measurement: For best results, use unsweetened applesauce at a 1:1 ratio when replacing corn syrup with applesauce in recipes.

11. Banana Puree – a decent sugar-free substitute for corn syrup

banana puree is good sugar free corn syrup substitute

Another excellent all-natural, sugar-free option is banana puree. Bananas are naturally sweet and make an ideal replacement for corn syrup when used correctly.

Ratio or measurement: Use one part of banana puree per two parts of corn syrup to avoid altering the flavor or texture of your recipe too much.

12. Date Paste

Dates are loaded with natural sugars and can make an excellent replacement for traditional sweeteners like high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) when used properly in recipes.

Ratio or measurement: To replace HFCS, use 1/3 cup date paste per 1/2 cup HFCS called for in your recipe; this will add natural sweetness with fewer calories and no added sugars!

13. Yacon Syrup – similar to corn syrup

yacon syrup is nice sugar free corn syrup replacement

Yacon syrup is derived from an Andean root vegetable and has been gaining popularity due to its low glycemic index and ability to provide sweetness without raising blood sugar levels like traditional sugars do.

Ratio or measurement: To replace corn syrup with yacon syrup, simply use one part yacon per two parts of corn syrup required in your recipe.

This will add subtle sweetness without the calories or health implications of traditional sugars!

14. Fruit concentrate

This sugar-free alternative uses fruit in its natural form to provide sweetness without adding any extra calories or unhealthy ingredients.

Ratio or measurement: To replace corn syrup with fruit concentrate, simply use one part concentrate per two parts of corn syrup called for in the recipe.

This will add subtle sweetness with the added bonus of providing some additional vitamins and minerals to your dish!

how to make corn syrup- homemade sugar-free corn syrup Alternatives

Homemade sugar-free corn syrup is a simple and healthy alternative to store-bought varieties.

This syrup uses just two ingredients – cornstarch and water – making it suitable for anyone following a variety of diets or trying to minimize their sugar intake. 

It’s also incredibly quick and easy to prepare, requiring only a few minutes of cook time.

To make the syrup, start by stirring 1/4 cup of cornstarch into 1 cup of cold water until it is completely dissolved.

Next, pour the mix into a medium-sized saucepan over medium heat and stir constantly till the mix thickens and turns glossy.

Once ready, remove the heat and let it cool before transferring to an airtight utensil and storing it in the fridge for a minimum of two weeks.

Not only is homemade sugar-free corn syrup healthier than its store-bought counterpart, but it’s also cheaper – costing less than $0.50 per batch!

Additionally, because it doesn’t contain any added sugars or preservatives, this syrup has no calories or carbohydrates, making it an excellent option for those looking to satisfy a sweet craving without compromising their health goals.

Substitute for corn syrup in the icing

When making frosting and icing recipes, you can substitute corn syrup with honey, agave syrup, or maple syrup. 

Honey is a natural sweetener that works especially well in icing because it adds an extra layer of flavor to the mix and helps keep the icing moist.

Agave syrup is also a great option because it has a milder flavor than honey and is lower on the glycemic index, indicating it won’t spike blood sugar levels like other forms of sugar.

Maple syrup provides a strong flavor that pairs perfectly with spices like cinnamon or nutmeg in your recipe.

All three of these substitutes are an excellent way to make your frosting without using corn syrup.

It’s vital to note that they are all sweeter than corn syrup and may require some adjustments to the rest of the ingredients in order to achieve the desired texture and sweetness level in the finished product.

Substitute for corn syrup in caramel

One delicious substitution for corn syrup in caramel is honey. Honey has a unique but subtle flavor and lends a smooth texture to the caramel.

Additionally, it can be used in the same proportions as corn syrup, making it an ideal substitute even for those who may not have access to corn syrup.

Other substitutions include molasses, agave nectar, maple syrup, and brown rice syrup. 

While all of these can use in place of corn syrup in caramel recipes, they each provide their own distinct flavor with varying levels of sweetness.

For instance, molasses has a deep flavor and darker hue than other options, while agave nectar provides a more neutral flavor, ideal for those who prefer less sweetness.

Ultimately, whichever substitute you choose for corn syrup will depend on the final taste that you are trying to achieve with your caramel recipe.

Substitute for corn syrup in candy

One viable option for replacing corn syrup in candy is honey. Honey is a natural sweetener used in confectionary recipes for centuries.

It contains higher levels of fructose than glucose, which makes it sweeter and more desirable than corn syrup.

When using honey to replace corn syrup in candy recipes, the ratio should be adjusted due to its higher sweetness level.

Additionally, it is important to consider the viscosity when replacing corn syrup with honey, as the two have different consistencies, which can alter the texture of the candy.

Honey also has additional benefits compared to corn syrup, such as being rich in vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants which can add nutritional value to candy recipes.

Lastly, some people may prefer using honey over corn syrup due to personal beliefs about health or food-related practices such as veganism or organic eating habits.

sugar-free substitute for corn syrup for baking

When baking without corn syrup, it is possible to substitute a few other ingredients which provide a similar texture and sweetness.

Honey or agave nectar are two of the most popular sugar-free substitutes for corn syrup, as they are both natural sweeteners with low glycemic index ratings.

Maple syrup is another popular option, although it does contain some sugar.

Date syrup is a good choice for those looking for an entirely sugar-free alternative to corn syrup and can use in place of honey or agave nectar as well.

Molasses is also an option but should be used sparingly as its distinctive flavor can overpower other ingredients in the recipe.

Coconut nectar and coconut palm sugar are two more alternatives that can provide a touch of natural sweetness to baked goods without any added sugar.

By experimenting with these different options, bakers can create delicious recipes free of corn syrup and refined sugars that still taste great!

How to Choose the Most Suitable Substitution Option for corn syrup

When selecting a substitution option for corn syrup, consider the following tips:

1. Sweetness Level: Corn syrup is known for its sweetness and its ability to prevent sugar crystallization in recipes. When choosing a substitution, consider the sweetness level of the alternative.

Options like golden syrup, agave nectar, or honey can provide a similar level of sweetness.

2. Viscosity and Texture: Corn syrup has a thick and sticky consistency. If the texture is important in your recipe, look for substitutes that offer a similar viscosity, such as golden syrup or maple syrup.

Keep in mind that some alternatives, like agave nectar or honey, may have a thinner consistency.

3. Flavor Profile: Corn syrup has a neutral flavor that allows other ingredients to shine. Consider the impact of the substitute’s flavor on your recipe. For example, if you prefer a subtle caramel flavor, try using golden syrup.

If you desire a hint of floral notes, consider using honey.

4. Recipe Compatibility: Consider the specific recipe you’re preparing and choose a substitution option that complements the other ingredients. Some alternatives may work better in certain recipes.

For instance, molasses can be a suitable replacement for dark corn syrup in baking recipes that require a rich and robust flavor.

5. Availability and Accessibility: Take into account the availability and accessibility of the substitution options in your area.

Some alternatives, such as agave nectar or honey, are widely available, while others may be more niche or region-specific.

6. Allergies and Dietary Restrictions: Consider any dietary restrictions or allergies when selecting a substitute.

For example, if you’re looking for a vegan option, agave nectar or maple syrup can be suitable choices.

7. Experiment and Adjust: Conduct a small-scale test with the substitute to gauge its impact on your recipe. Start by replacing a small portion of the corn syrup and evaluate the taste, texture, and overall result.

Adjust the quantity or make any necessary flavor adjustments based on your taste preferences.

Conclusion on sugar-free substitute for corn syrup

In conclusion, using sugar-free substitutes for corn syrup in your recipes is not only healthier but also provides you with a variety of flavors and textures to experiment with. 

In this blog post, we discussed 14 sugar-free substitutes for corn syrup, their ratios, and tips on using them in your recipes. 

As a house cook or chef, it is essential to be creative and open-minded when experimenting with substitutes so that you can find the perfect substitute for the specific recipe you are working on.

FAQs on sugar-free substitute for corn syrup

Q1. What is similar to corn syrup?

Similar to corn syrup are other types of syrups, including glucose syrup, malt syrup, high fructose corn syrup (HFCS), maple syrup and molasses.

All are forms of sugar that can be used in cooking and baking. Each type of sweetener has a unique flavor profile that may affect the taste or texture of foods when used as an ingredient.

Additionally, different syrups have varying levels of sweetness, which must be taken into account when substituting one for another in recipes.

Q2. What is a replacement for corn syrup?

A replacement for corn syrup is an alternative sweetener such as honey, agave syrup, molasses or coconut sugar. These alternatives have a much lower glycemic index than corn syrup and provide additional health benefits.

Additionally, there are other non-caloric sweeteners, such as stevia or monk fruit, that can be used in place of corn syrup if desired.

Q3. How do you substitute sugar for corn syrup?

The best substitution for corn syrup is maple syrup or molasses. To substitute sugar, use an equal amount of maple syrup or molasses and reduce the other liquids in the formula by 1/4 cup for each cup of syrup or molasses used.

Additionally, you can substitute honey for sugar at a ratio of three-fourths cup of honey for every cup of sugar.

Alternatively, suppose you do not have either of these ingredients on hand. In that case, brown rice syrup can also be substituted as a one-to-one replacement for corn syrup.

Leave a Comment