10 Easy to Find, Reasonable Plum Tomatoes Substitutes

Love tomatoes? Then you’ll love plum tomatoes! These guys are sweet and tart, with a firm texture that makes them perfect for cooking, have fewer seeds, and make sauce and tomato paste. Although plum tomatoes are available year-round but still can’t find them, try the best Plum tomatoes substitutes.

What type of tomato is a plum tomato? What do plum tomatoes taste like?

A plum tomato is a type of tomato that is small and oval-shaped. Plum tomatoes are usually red, but they can also be yellow or green. They have a sweet taste and are often used in sauces, soups, and salads.

A plum tomato is a small, oval-shaped tomato that is usually red or yellow in color. Plum tomatoes are sweeter and juicier than other types of tomatoes, and they are often used in salads and salsa. Plum tomatoes also have thinner skin than other types of tomatoes, making them more delicate and easier to bruise.

Best Plum Tomatoes Substitutes

1. ROMA TOMATO- Italian style plum tomatoes substitute

Roma tomatoes are a good choice for substitution because they have a similar shape and texture to plum tomatoes. They also have a little sweet flavor that can complement the acidity of other ingredients in your dish.

Roma Tomato is a type of plum tomato that is commonly used in salads and as a garnish. It is also called Italian plum tomatoes. Roma tomatoes are the most popular variety of plum tomatoes.

roma tomatoes are a good choice for substitution because they have a similar shape and texture to plum tomatoes

This type of tomato is also grown in both indoor and outdoor gardens.

When cooked, Roma tomatoes create a rich sauce that is perfect for pasta dishes. They can also be utilized to produce soups or stews that are full of flavor. Roma tomatoes can be eaten fresh, canned, or cooked.

2. SAN MARZANO – Second Best Substitute for Plum tomatoes

San Marzano tomatoes are a variety of plum tomatoes. They are popular for their taste, which is said to be sweeter than regular tomatoes. There are several types of San Marzano tomatoes that you can buy in your local supermarket or at a farmer’s market.

San Marzano has fewer seeds with thick flesh, and the flavor is richer, sweeter, and less acidic, just like plum tomatoes.

One of the reasons why San Marzano tomatoes are so beloved is because of their unique flavor profile. While regular tomatoes are often described as being tart and acidic, San Marzano is said to have a sweeter taste that is still well-balanced. Also, these tomatoes are very easy to grow in your garden.

San Marzano tomato originated from the Italian region of Campania. the name “san marzano” is derived from a nearby town known as san marzano sul sarno. San Marzano tomatoes are very popular in Italy and other parts of Europe, especially for their taste and ease of growing.

They are easy to go with different kinds of pasta and pizza recipes.

So without thinking twice, swap plum tomatoes with San Marzano tomatoes for sauces and stews; you will not regret it! Check Best San Marzano Tomatoes.

3. Substitute CHERRY TOMATOES for Plum Tomatoes

I knew that cherry tomatoes would be a better option because they were smaller, sweeter, and more firm than the plums tomatoes. The plum tomatoes are great for sauces or soups, but I enjoyed cherry tomatoes in salads or as a snack on their own.

They were a healthier option, and I didn’t have to worry about them going bad as quickly. Overall, I thought the cherry tomatoes were a great substitute for the plum tomatoes. While cherry tomatoes are good for salads, you can use them to make pasta sauce.

4. GRAPE TOMATOES-A Good Replacement for Plum Tomatoes 

Grape Tomatoes are another excellent choice to replace plum tomatoes, which are also known as paste tomatoes in sauce and salad. Grape tomatoes are small and sweet with a thinner skin than most tomatoes, which makes them perfect for canning. They are also easier to grow in a greenhouse or polytunnel than other varieties of tomatoes.

5. Substituting CANNED TOMATOES for Paste Tomatoes is A Great Idea.

Canned tomatoes are also best for making pasta sauce. Canned tomatoes are a great way to add to stews or make a quick and easy pasta sauce; substitute canned tomatoes for plum tomatoes.

Canned tomatoes are a great way to add flavor and depth to your sauce without having to spend hours cooking it. Plus, they’re usually cheaper than fresh tomatoes. Just make sure to get the sauce that’s right for your taste buds. Plus, they’re easy to find in most grocery stores.

Also, you can make your own by peeling any regular tomatoes and processing heat-then storing them into a glass jar for later use. Canned Tomatoes are also known as Tinned tomatoes.

Read More- Try Best Substitutes for Stewed Tomatoes

6. CAMPARI TOMATOES- Decent Alternative to Plum Tomatoes

If you’re looking for a substitution for plum tomatoes in your cooking, try using Campari tomatoes instead.

Campari tomatoes are a type smaller than plum tomatoes but big enough than cherry tomatoes; they are around tomato that is often used in salads and other dishes where plum tomatoes would typically be used. 

While they may not be similar in taste or texture to plum tomatoes, Campari tomatoes can be utilized in most recipes that call for plum tomatoes. Campari tomatoes are juicier and have low acidity than Plum tomatoes.

Campari tomatoes are a type of tomato that is often used in salads and other dishes. Their sweetness pairs well with savory flavors, and they are a rich source of vitamins A and C. 

To add a little additional flavor to your dishes, Campari tomatoes may be a good choice. They’re easy to locate in most grocery stores, or you can order them online. Give them an attempt in your next recipe!

7. Try REGULAR TOMATO Instead of Plum Tomatoes 

You can substitute regular tomatoes in any recipe that calls for plum or processed tomatoes. There may be a little dissimilarity in flavor, but the overall taste will still be delicious. So go ahead and enjoy your meal!

You can add them to stews, curries, sauces, soups, and more. Just be sure to chop them up into small pieces so that they cook evenly. Plum tomatoes tend to be a bit sweeter than regular tomatoes, so you may want to add slight extra sugar or honey to your dish if you are using regular tomatoes. 

With a little creativity, you can use any type of tomato in many different recipes. So have fun cooking and enjoy your meal!​

8. SUN-DRIED TOMATOES- Quick Plum Tomato Substitution 

Substitute sun-dried tomatoes for plum tomatoes in most recipes. The differences between the two types of tomatoes will depend on the recipe and your preferences.

As sun-dried tomatoes are a little sweeter and more intense in flavor than plum tomatoes, whole plum tomatoes are often firmer and less juicy. To make the best substitution, consider your specific recipe and adjust any time or flavorings that may be necessary. 

Try using sun-dried tomatoes with some additional seasonings to mimic their texture and sweetness. Ultimately, it is totally on you to experiment and see which tomato works best in your recipe.

9. Do You Heard About SCORPIO RED TOMATOES! If So, Try it for the next Plum Tomatoes Recipes. 

Yes, you can substitute Scorpio Red tomatoes for plum tomatoes. The main dissimilarity between these two types of tomatoes is that the plums tend to have a firmer texture than the reds. This can make them ideal for use in dishes like salsa and pasta sauces, where you need the finished product to have a thick consistency.

you can use scorpio Red tomatoes as a great alternative for plum tomatoes

Additionally, Scorpio Red tomatoes are slightly sweeter, which can make them more ideal for use in recipes that call for a bit of sweetness. However, both types of tomatoes have a delicious flavor and can be used interchangeably depending on your preferences. So if you need to substitute one type of tomato for another in a recipe, feel free to do so without worry.

10. TOMATO PUREE- Decent Plum Tomato Alternate

Alternate tomato puree for plum tomatoes. The taste will be slightly different, but the overall flavor will be similar. However, if you’re looking for a more authentic Italian flavor, you should stick with plum tomatoes.

Whether you choose tomato puree or diced tomatoes will depend on your recipe and personal preferences. You may need to adjust the number of seasonings you add to your dish, as pureed tomatoes tend to be a bit more concentrated. Be sure to taste and adjust the seasoning as needed to bring out the best flavor.

What’s the difference between tomatoes and plum tomatoes?

Tomatoes and plum tomatoes are different in a number of ways.

Plum tomatoes VS Regular tomatoes

The main difference is that tomatoes are round, while plum tomatoes are oval-shaped.

Additionally, plum tomatoes have fewer seeds than regular tomatoes, and they also have firmer flesh. Finally, plum tomatoes tend to be sweeter than their counterparts.

Whether you are using plum tomatoes or regular tomatoes in your cooking, they are both delicious and nutritious!

Overall, it’s vital to choose the right kind of tomato for your recipe, as they will each impart a different flavor.

Read More- Try Best Cheese substitutes for Basket Cheese

Final Thought On Substitute for plum tomatoes

While there is no perfect substitute for plum tomatoes, there are several options that can be used in their place. For example, Roma tomatoes can be used as a substitute in many recipes.

Additionally, cherry or grape tomatoes can also be used as a substitute for plum tomatoes. When using either of these substitutes, it is important to keep in mind that the cooking time may need to be adjusted.

Overall, with a little bit of creativity, it is possible to find a suitable substitute for plum tomatoes in most recipes.

FAQs Related to Plum Tomatoes & Its Alternatives

Q1. What’s another name for plum tomatoes?

Another Name for plum tomatoes is Paste or Processing tomatoes.

Q2. What tomato is closest to plum tomato?

Roma, San Marzano, Cherry Tomatoes, and Grape Tomatoes.

Q3. What is plum tomato Good For?

Plum tomatoes are great for making sauces, soups, and stews. They are also good for roasting and can be used in salads and salsas. Plum tomatoes have a thick skin and a fleshy interior. They are very juicy and have a sweet, acidic flavor. Plum tomatoes are available year-round.

Q4. Is Roma and plum tomatoes the same?

Yes, Roma and Plum kind of the same Tomatoes but has some distinctions.

Roma is a variety of plum tomatoes but is smaller and more tender than plum tomatoes, with a sweeter and less acidic flavor.

Also, unlike plums which mature on the vine as they grow larger, Romas are picked while they are still green in color and then allowed to mature on their own. This is why Romas have thicker skin than plums and don’t burst easily when grilled or roasted, making them perfect for causing, mashing, or canning.

Plums are usually available year-round at grocery stores and farmers’ markets, while Romas are typically only harvested during the summer months. In addition, plum tomatoes are less expensive than Romas, making them a better choice for cooking or canning.

Overall, while these two types of tomatoes are very similar in appearance and taste, they do have some noteworthy differences that make them unique from each other.

Q5. Can you substitute plum tomatoes for Roma tomatoes?

Yes, plum tomatoes can be substituted for Roma tomatoes in many recipes. Both plum and Roma tomatoes are varieties of Italian tomatoes that are close in size, shape, and flavor. However, plum tomatoes tend to be a bit juicier and have a slightly sweeter flavor than Roma tomatoes.

When replacing one for the other in a recipe, you may want to add a little less water or cook the dish for a shorter amount of time to account for the additional moisture in the plum tomatoes.

Q6. What are tin plum tomatoes?

Tin plum tomatoes are a variety of small, cherry-sized tomatoes that are typically canned or jarred. They are often used in salads, salsa, and other dishes where a small tomato is desired. Tin plums may also be referred to as grape tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, or baby plum tomatoes.

Q7. How to store plum tomatoes?

If you are searching for the most suitable way to store plum tomatoes, look no further! The key to keeping these delicious fruits fresh is to keep them cool and dry. Here are some tips on how to do just that:

1. Choose a cool, dark spot in your kitchen for storing plum tomatoes. A cupboard or pantry shelf is an excellent place to keep these fruits fresh.

2. Make sure that your plum tomatoes are completely dry before storing them. Pat the fruit with a paper towel or cloth to remove any moisture from the surface before putting it away.

3. Keep your plum tomatoes away from other produce, especially juicy fruits like apples and peaches. The moisture from these fruits can cause the tomatoes to rot.

4. Store plum tomatoes in a single layer on a plate or in a shallow container. This will help to keep them from bruising or getting squished.

5. Check on your plum tomatoes often, and remove any that are starting to look soft or overripe. Eating these fruits as soon as possible is the best way to ensure that they are at their freshest and most delicious.

If you want to keep your plum tomatoes fresh for as long as possible, follow these simple tips for storing them. With a little care and attention, you can enjoy this delicious fruit all year round!​

Q8. Where can you buy plum tomatoes?

You can buy plum tomatoes at many grocery stores or farmer’s markets. Some popular varieties of plum tomatoes are San Marzano, Roma, and Amish Paste. They are typically found in the produce section or sometimes the canned goods aisle.

Q9. Can I substitute diced tomatoes for plum tomatoes?

You cannot substitute diced tomatoes for plum tomatoes. Plum tomatoes have a thick skin and rich flavor that makes them ideal in recipes like pasta sauces or salsa.

Diced tomatoes are best used in recipes where they will be simmered briefly, similar to stewed tomatoes. If you substitute diced tomatoes for plum tomatoes in a recipe, the final dish will be watery and lack flavor.

Q10. Can I use chopped tomatoes instead of plums?

Yes, you can use chopped tomatoes instead of plum tomatoes in most recipes. The flavor will be a little different, but the results will still be delicious.

Leave a Comment