11+ Top Sweet pickle relish substitute | Get similar Flavor

Sweet pickle relish is one of those condiments that brings back a flood of memories for me. Every time I take it, I’m transported back to my childhood kitchen, where my mom would be busily preparing our family meal.

Whether she was using it as a topping on burgers or hot dogs or stirring it into her famous potato salad, sweet pickle relish always added something special to the dish.

If you’re searching for a method to add some extra flavor to your next meal, give this delicious condiment a try!

However, nothing can beat the taste of homemade sweet pickle relish. Whether you are a chef or cook, food lover or mom, this recipe is sure to be a hit! It’s easy to make and can be enjoyed on everything from hot dogs to burgers to salads.

So get cooking and want the delicious taste of sweet pickle relish! But what do if you don’t have sweet pickle relish in your kitchen?

Don’t worry! There is many sweet pickle relish substitute! With some simple ingredients, you can have a delicious and hearty condiment that is perfect for topping your favorite dishes.

So why not try it today? I can guarantee you that you won’t be disappointed! Keep reading on to find out more to give your cooking the next level.

What is a sweet pickle relish?

Sweet pickle relish is a type of pickled relish made with sweet pickles.

It is often used as a condiment on sandwiches and hot dogs. Sweet pickle relish can also be used in recipes such as salads, dips, and sauces.

What does relish taste like?

Relish generally has a sweet and tangy taste, with a slightly vinegary kick.

The exact flavor will vary depending on the type of relish and what ingredients are used to make it. For example, cucumber relish is usually cool and refreshing. In contrast, pepper relish can have a bit more of a fiery flavor. 

 No matter what, relish is a great way to add some extra flavor to your favorite dishes.

What is sweet pickle relish made of?

Sweet pickle relish is typically made from a combination of cucumbers, sugar, vinegar, and spices.

The precise ingredients and proportions vary depending on the recipe, but the end result is always a sweet and tangy condiment that is ideal for topping off burgers and hot dogs or adding to potato salad and coleslaw.

What is a substitute for sweet pickle relish?

If you’re in hurry, go through this section. There are many substitutes for sweet pickle relish, including:

diced pickles, diced cucumbers, diced onions, chopped green olives, dill pickles, freeze-dried dill, Piccalilli relish, capers, Indian chutney, Chicago-style relish, chopped green peppers, bread and butter pickle, celery stalks, Indian relish, etc.

You can also make your own sweet pickle relish by combining equal parts diced pickles, sugar, and vinegar.

1. dill pickles- Perfect substitute for sweet pickle

When making a dish that calls for sweet pickle relish, you can substitute dill pickle instead. This will alter the flavor of the recipe, but it will still be delicious. Just make sure to adjust the other flavors accordingly.

Dill pickles are relatively low in calories and fat. They are a good source of vitamin C and other nutrients.

If you are on a low-sodium diet, you may want to limit your intake of dill pickles. You can also buy “low-sodium” or “no salt added” varieties.

when making a dish that calls for sweet pickle relish you can alternate dill pickle instead

The dill pickle is a cucumber that has been pickled in a brine (salt water) solution and, after that, sealed in a jar or container. The cucumber is usually soaked in the brine for a few days to weeks, depending on the desired level of sourness.

These are often used as a condiment or topping on sandwiches and burgers. They can also be eaten alone as a snack. Some people like to apply them to salads for a crunchy texture.

Dill pickles can be stored in the refrigerator for several months. Once opened, they should be taken and consumed within a few weeks.

2. Freeze-dried dill- Suitable Sweet Pickle Relish Alternative

Substitute Freeze dried dill for sweet pickle relish in any recipe that calls for sweet pickle relish. This will add a nice dill flavor to the dish without making it too sour.

If you want to add a little sweetness, you can add a small amount of honey or sugar to the recipe as well. And add to tuna salad or potato salad. Sprinkle on top of a baked potato with sour cream, cottage cheese, or yogurt.

Add to omelets, quiches, and stuffings or use in any recipe that calls for dill weed.

Dried dill has a more intense flavor than fresh dill, so you may want to use less than the recipe calls. To rehydrate, simply soak in water for about 15 minutes.

Dried dill weed will last for months in your pantry and is always ready when you need it.

3. Piccalilli relish- Similar to Sweet Pickle Relish

Piccalilli relish is a chopped vegetable pickle famous in the United Kingdom and other Commonwealth nations. It is usually made from cucumbers, onions, cauliflower, gherkins, and various spices. 

The word piccalilli can also refer to a dish of chopped pickled vegetables (often including chili peppers) mixed with mustard or mayonnaise.

Piccalilli relish has a tangy, sweet, and spicy flavor that would work well as a substitute for sweet pickle relish.

It is often used as a condiment, particularly on cold meats and cheeses. It is also a common ingredient in Ploughman’s lunches and cheese boards.

In the United Kingdom, piccalilli is usually sold in jars or plastic tubs. In North America, it is more typically found in cans.

4. Green olives- Suitable Alternative to Sweet Pickle Relish

If you’re looking for a substitution for sweet pickle relish, try using green olives instead. They’ll add a similar salty and briny flavor to your dish. Plus, they’re a great way to change up the flavors in your favorite recipes.

This will give the salad a slightly different flavor, but it will still be delicious.

Read More- Best Healthy Alternative to olives

5. Try Indian chutney instead of Sweet Pickle Relish

Indian chutney is a condiment that is popular in the Indian subcontinent, and it is a great method to add flavor and depth to a dish.

There are many different types of chutneys, and they can be either sweet, savory, or spicy. Some common ingredients in chutneys include Tamarind, mangoes, limes, lemons, ginger, garlic, onion, chili peppers, and cumin.

Chutneys are typically served as an accompaniment to curries, idlis, dosas, and other savory dishes. They can also be used as a dipping sauce or for sandwiches and wraps. Chutneys can be store-bought or made at home.

Homemade chutneys are often more flavorful and fresh-tasting than store-bought varieties.

When making chutneys at home, it is important to use fresh ingredients. This will ensure that the chutney has the best flavor possible. Chutneys can be prepared in advance and preserved in the fridge for up to a week.

So you can add Indian chutney in the place of sweet relish, ketchup, or other condiments. They are also a significant origin of vitamins A and C.

If you want to make a healthier version, you can use low-fat yogurt or Coconut milk instead of cream.

You can even make chutney without any dairy products at all!

6. Capers – An excellent Replacement for Sweet Pickle relish

If you’re looking for a substitution for sweet pickle relish, try using capers. Capers are small flower buds that are typically pickled in vinegar. They have a refreshing sour, tangy flavor with a slide acidic taste that can add a nice zing to any dish.

They are high in vitamins and minerals. The most commonly consumed part of this plant is the fruit which can be either eaten raw or cooked.

7. Chicago-style relish- Spicy Substitute for sweet pickle relish

Chicago-style relish is a yellowish to green pickled relish made from chopped vegetables and spices, typically used as a condiment.

The most common vegetables include cucumbers, onions, bell peppers, and tomatoes. Chicago-style relishes are usually sweet with a vinegar tang, although some brands add hot peppers for a spicy kick.

If you want to make a Chicago-style hot dog, you need to substitute sweet pickle relish for the standard green relish. This gives the hot dog a sweeter flavor that is reminiscent of the Windy City.

Read More- Ideal Alternative to green curry paste

8. chopped green peppers- Easy sweet pickle relish replacement

If you want to substitute chopped green peppers for sweet pickle relish in your recipe, you must adjust the other ingredients accordingly.

You may need to add more sugar or vinegar to balance out the flavors.

9. Bread and butter pickles

In a bread and butter pickle, the cucumbers are usually sliced thinly or even grated, making for a more refreshing bite than in a sweet pickle relish.

The spices are also more subdued, letting the natural flavor of the cucumbers shine through. If you’re looking for a lighter, brighter version of sweet pickle relish, give bread and butter pickles a try.

10. celery stalks

When making your own sweet pickle relish, you can substitute celery stalks for the cucumbers. This will give the dish a slightly different flavor, but it will still be delicious.

Just make sure to chop the celery into small pieces so that it will blend in well with the other ingredients.

11. cucumbers – Easy sweet pickle relish substitute

If you want to replace cucumbers with sweet pickle relish, you can do so by following these simple steps:

1. Start with fresh, firm cucumbers. Peel and seed them next, and chop them into small pieces.

2. Soak the cucumbers in a mixture of vinegar and water for at least an hour.

3. Drain the cucumbers and add them to a food processor or blender, along with some sugar, salt, and spices (such as mustard seed, celery seed, or dill weed). Puree the mixture until it’s smooth.

4. Transfer the pureed cucumber mixture to a clean jar or container and store it in the refrigerator. It will keep for several weeks.

12. Indian relish

To make an Indian-style sweet pickle relish, substitute chopped onion, green chili pepper, and fresh ginger for the sweetener. Soak the mixture overnight in a mixture of vinegar and water.

indian relish is a popular sweet pickle relish substitute

The next day, drain the mixture and add sugar to taste. It is preserved in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

How to make sweet relish from pickles


1. Pickles

2. Sugar

3. Vinegar

4. Water

5. Salt

6. Celery seed (optional)

7. Onion (optional)

8. Garlic (optional)

9. Peppers (optional)

10. Mustard seed (optional)


1. Start with clean pickles. If you are using freshly picked cucumbers, wash them thoroughly. If you are using store-bought pickles, drain the juice and rinse the cucumbers.

You can slice the pickles or leave them whole, depending on your preference.

2. In a large pot, mix sugar, vinegar, water, and salt together and bring to a boil.

3. Apply the cucumbers to the pot and let them cook for 3-4 minutes.

4. Remove the cucumbers from the pot with a slotted spoon and place them in a bowl.

5. Reserve the liquid from the pot.

6. Add celery seed, onion, garlic, peppers, and mustard seed to the reserved liquid and bring to a boil.

7. Pour the mixture over the cucumbers and let cool.

8. Once cooled, you can store the relish in a jar or container in the fridge for up to 2 weeks. Enjoy!

What’s the difference between sweet relish and sweet pickle relish?

Sweet relish is made from chopped-up pickles that are soaked in sugar. Sweet pickle relish is made from pickles that are soaked in a sugar and vinegar solution.

The two condiments are similar but have a few key differences. Sweet relish is made with water, vinegar, sugar, and cornstarch. It contains a slightly sweet flavor and a crunchy texture.

Sweet pickle relish, on the other hand, is made with cucumbers, water, vinegar, sugar, and spices. It has a more traditional pickle flavor and a softer texture.

So, which should you use? It actually depends on your personal preference and what you’re using it for. If you want a sweeter relish for something like a hot dog, go with a sweet relish.

If you want a more traditional pickle flavor for something like potato salad, go with sweet pickle relish.

Read More- Ideal Substitute for Tabasco Sauce

Wrap up on substitute for sweet pickle relish

There are many substitutes for sweet pickle relish, including diced pickles, diced green olives, diced tomatoes, and chopped cucumbers.

You can also make your own relish by combining any of these ingredients with sugar, vinegar, and spices.

If you need a sweeter relish, you can add honey or fruit juice. Whatever you choose, your relish will be delicious!

While there are many substitutes for sweet pickle relish, none are quite as good as the real thing. If you’re looking for a close second, try substituting dill pickle relish or cornichons. Otherwise, enjoy your meal without the sweet pickle relish!

FAQ’s on sweet pickle relish substitute

Q1. Is relish just chopped pickles?

Relish is a type of condiment made from chopped pickles or other vegetables. It is typically used as a topping on burgers and hot dogs. Relish can also be used in recipes such as tuna salad and potato salad.

No, relish is not just chopped pickles. Relish is a condiment made from chopped pickles, onions, and other vegetables that are typically seasoned with vinegar, sugar, and spices. It is used as a topping or side dish for various foods, such as hot dogs, hamburgers, and sandwiches.

Q2. What kind of relish do you use for hot dogs?

There are many types of relish that can be used for hot dogs, including sweet relish, dill relish, and even pickle relish. Eventually, it comes down to personal preference as to which type of relish you use.

Some people even like to mix different types of relish together to create their own unique flavor.

Q3. Is dill pickle relish the same as sweet relish?

No, dill pickle relish is not the same as a sweet relish. Sweet relish is made with sweeter ingredients like sugar and corn syrup. In contrast, dill pickle relish includes vinegar and dillweed for a more tart flavor.

No, dill pickle relish is not the same as a sweet relish. Dill pickle relish is made from diced pickles, while sweet relish is made from chopped cucumbers. Sweet relish also contains sugar and vinegar, while dill pickle relish does not.

Q4. Why are pickles called relish?

There’re a few different theories out there as to why pickles are called relish. One theory is that pickles were originally called “relish” because they were a popular side dish served with meals.

Another theory is that the word “relish” comes from the Old French word meaning “to dig up.” This likely refers to the process of making pickled cucumbers, which involves digging up the cucumbers from their vine.

Whatever the origin of the word, there’s no doubt that pickles are delicious and versatile food. It can be taken on its own or as a condiment or side dish.

Pickles come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and flavors, so there’s sure to be a pickle out there for everyone to enjoy!

Q9. How do you eat relish?

Relish is often eaten as a condiment and added to foods such as hamburgers, hot dogs, or salads.

However, some people prefer to eat it straight from the jar with a spoon. It can also be used as an ingredient in recipes, such as relish dip, relish trays, and even relish cakes.

Q10. Is sweet relish healthy?

Yes, sweet relish is healthy. It is a great origin of fiber and vitamins A, C, and K. Furthermore, it contains antioxidants that protect against cell damage.

Still, there is no standard answer to this question as it depends on individual dietary needs and preferences. Some people may find that sweet relish is a healthy addition to their diet, while others may choose to avoid it due to the high sugar content.

Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide whether or not sweet relish is a healthy part of their diet.

Q11. What is the best relish for hot dogs?

There are many different types of relish, so it really depends on your personal preference. Some popular choices include sweet pickle relish, dill relish, Chicago-style relish, and sauerkraut.

You can also test with different combinations of these flavors to create your own unique taste. Whichever relish you choose, make sure to pile it on thick for the ultimate hot dog experience!

Q12. How to use sweet pickle relish?

Sweet pickle relish can add a unique flavor to many different dishes. It can be used as a condiment, added to salads, or used in savory recipes. Sweet pickle relish is also a popular ingredient in many prepared foods such as dressings, dips, and sauces.

If you’re searching for methods to add more flavor to your food, consider using sweet pickle relish. 

Here are a few suggestions on how to use sweet pickle relish:

-Add sweet pickle relish to your favorite condiment recipe. It can add a unique flavor to ketchup, mustard, or mayonnaise.
-Add sweet pickle relish to your next batch of homemade salad dressing.
-Make a savory dip or sauce by adding sweet pickle relish to plain yogurt or sour cream.
-Add sweet pickle relish to baked goods such as quick bread, muffins or pancakes for a unique flavor.
-Use sweet pickle relish as a topping for burgers, hot dogs, or sandwiches.
-Add sweet pickle relish to coleslaw or potato salad for a tangy twist.
-Make a sweet and sour sauce for pork, chicken, or fish by combining sweet pickle relish with vinegar, sugar, and spices.

Leave a Comment